Incorporate the best of the 2
I am almost tempted to say I like the first one better. (minus the single sound effect of course) The First one was a bit more fast paced and the second one was a little too flashy and complicated with some of the moves. Maybe it would help to thicken the lines of the Stick figures, and try to have more actual fighting in the movie (if you know what I mean). Good job for someone who is just starting out.