Both movies were awesome although I preferred Luis's a bit more. (sorry Tim)
I just really lloved the way it was more of a story and actually had some nice jokes in it. Also, the photoshopped backgrounds were awesome.
Tim's effort is still above my own standards and I loved the bit with the monkey. The ending was fairly amusing too, in it's own way.
A great start to what will hopefully be a long-standing NG tradition.