sucky

work on the sound.
work on the animation.
the violence.
the....
the...
the story.
then i'ttl be good.
oh yeah work on the humor.

Lazy

Most of this movie seemed like an unfinished project. Some drawings and scenes were left unfinished it seemed, while others were obviously more complete. Equal time should have been spent on each scene to give it a more completed feel.

wtf??????????

waste of time crappy version of the movie

cool

dont listen to the other palyer haters,this was very good.cant wait for part 2

Alright...

This is just a decent piece. One huge problem was the lack of music, as well as very little sound at all. With some good music, this would be a much better entry.

Other than that, the piece is only a decent piece of animation. There is too much "words in the darkness" before the actual animation begins. I like the idea of retelling the story that comes before LOTR, but it could have been done a little better. And since you didn't actually write this story (that was Prof. Tolkien), I'm only gonna give it a 5. I think you have potential though, so I'll just consider this a work-in-progress.