decided to play this after trying 3-4/5-6 games of the sequel, and the stories where all pretty good. A great RPG maker adventure game for sure. Personaly rate the stories Penelope>House>Maniac>Tyler.
Unless you count the blooper mirror scene; D
(could not resist that joke; p)
Personally I think Tyler's storylines conflict too much with eachother.
Unless I stretch the story somewhat and assume Mary is Abby and that the dad made a deal with her, the story end up with inconsistencies, And there is not enough there to make that assumption either. there where also 2 minor issues 1 you flipped the equation in the Penelope chest puzzle it should be "substract the third number from the first number", (1-4≠3) 2 by removing the press X to remove blindfold at the start you could make this tablet/phone accessible, just an idea.
So I can't give you full marks still the rest of it was great so a nice 4/5