Yo this guy called Redberet posted this on his discord server and told me ur bad
Hello there people of Newgrounds! This is my first ever upload on Newgrounds, and hopefully it will not get alot of hate.
First of all, I would like to say that I started animating 2 weeks ago and this is my nineth animation, And I am indeed sorry if it is not very good.
Also, I read the rules on Newgrounds and I didn't find anything that says that you cannot upload Minecraft Animations, BUT incase if it is not allowed, I will remove this Animation asap.
Either way, thank you very much for watching this animation and have a nice day/night! :D
Yo this guy called Redberet posted this on his discord server and told me ur bad
Neat...
Thanks. :)
Wow! Its good to be ur firsts animations in Mine-imator!
I recommend you practice a lot and search differents programs to animate, really I love Mine-imator, but sometimes it would be short if u want to be an 3D Animator in the future, we didn't know.
Improve, search rigs, watch professional mc animations, don't be slow movig the character and talk with other animators for feedback ;)...
Thank you! I will be probably downloading Cinema 4D soon, since that's what most of the best Minecraft Animators use.
first thing first... Yes Minecraft is allowed. there is even a whole section entirely made of minecraft animations. Yes, and a lot of jokes, bad puns, weird builds, troll recipe etc. So no worries.
On to the review!
I'll be frank with you, This feels the same way as the house... unfinished. Unpolished, missing core part.
Graphic and animation wise, this is fine. It's clear to see you lied about when exactly you started learning animation.
'How to make a story' would be a great book for you. Doesn't matter where or how you acquire it, its content will do wonder with your work. Too much is left unanswered, there's nothing to talk about, there's nothing happening, there's no joke, no pun, no punchline... If you were trying for humour, i'm sorry to say you have failed. If you were trying for emotional, you also failed... If you were trying to be relatable, you, unfortunately, failed. Where is the message? What is the goal? Who even are you? Why minecraft? Do you love it? Is this your experience?
And oh god it's slow like my grandma's driving. It goes nowhere at the speed of a snail.
Music choice is.... uninspired. I've seen worse. And at least, you put sound and music in. That's great!
If you look at it stricly for the animation, this is fine. Good, even. There's nothing wrong.
If you look at it as someone looking for entertainement of any kind, this is bad. real bad. Unless you actually like watching nothing happen for no reason.
Here's another analogy... this is a painting. it looks good, but it doesnt do much other than that.
it's a beautiful girl without a brain and a heart.
it's life without life.
Work on you script. with a story of any kind, even if its just a one-liner or a joke about something stupid like a creeper exploding for no reason, it would be a bilion time better. Think about what you want to achieve with your animation. If you are only into it because you like to animate, perdiod, then try to hook up with someone who has a better idea of a story or a sense of humor. Many animator do this, you know. it's not uncommon. Most people have one talent, one passion and can't afford to deal with anything else so they ask others to fill in where they can't.
In case you don't know, 0 and 1 star rating will eventually bring down your submission. But even though this is lacking, it's not bad. all you need to a total rating of 1,5 and higher in order to keep afloat. But even if your submission ends up in the gutter, don't give up. (actuals number differ a bit but you get the idea)
Thank you very much for all this feedback! I actually didn't expect anyone to write so much on something like this. I really appreciate it! :D
The only thing I don't really understand is what do you exactly mean by - You lied about when exactly you started learning animation.
I don't wanna advertise or anything, But my youtube channel is "Creeperboy Animations" (You can find it by going on my main channel and then from my Featured channels to my Animation channel),
and that is where I post all my animations. My first animation was posted on 17th August, which, I wouldn't really recommend watching since it's very horrible. xD
But again, thank you for all this feedback!
Nice one! Just make the character walk faster and build faster , it was pretty long , But I can't do better. Nice man keep continuing and you will grow.
Thank you!!