Beautiful!

Though short it has so much emotion behind it...i would love to see more of your work *giggles*

Some great art here.

Some bad animation... if there was any.

You have a great style, your colour variation worked wonderfully, it wasn't too rough or agressive but a sombre pallet that worked well with the beautiful choice of music.

I love your art but feel disappointed that it was wasted on something with such lack of animation.

I really hope to see more from you.

Holy Crap

Dude this is excellent...Just a bit sort. Very well drawn and stuff.

Lot of potential

Hard to rate this too high at this length, but given my non-existent attention span I rarely watch movies to the end so it was pretty satisfying for me to find something that I could.

Art was excellent, not really enough animation here to comment on, but I'm sure with more time you could produce something epic. Not got my speakers in so cant say much about the sound.

You definitely shouldn't think of this as noobish, the small amount here showed a lot of talent that we'll hopefully see at its full potential in the future.

You have great style

But this is very unsatisfying. The character, the colors and the style looked fantastic. But the animation was bad on this short in that...there was none, except for some tweening. If you add some more time onto future works, and find a good balance between shading and character detail so that you won't be afraid of frame by frame, you'll be diabolical here. I look forward to seeing more from ya'