Spear and Warrior

Share Collapse

Author Comments

I tried to polish my rusty animation capabilities with these small walk, idle, attack cycles.
As always, it took more hours than expected.
Style is baded on that of a popular WII rts game.


I'll try to be polite with this review.

Your movie is... well... okay I guess. To make this simple, here is my list of the good and bad aspects of this submission.

Good: Animation quality was descent and has much potential.

Bad:No audio whatsoever. Also, there seems to be a lack of plot, which I find to be less entertaining. Humor was dry except for the very end, which was not the best by itself. Also I am not a fan of looping videos.

Conclusion: Not good, but with some major refinements in style, later submissions might have potential.

People find this review helpful!


i liked it, thought backgrounds and shading was great but people dont really accept tests here so make a skit and then post it and you wont get blammed

People find this review helpful!
ThomasNoppers responds:

Thanks for the advice!

This would be good...

If it wasn't completely pointless. If you worked with other artists, then you could probably have something other than a plotless movie.

ThomasNoppers responds:

On the other hand i do not really care wether if people want a plot

thats it?

sorry man, but not only does this NOT make any sense, but its short and stupid. try adding a story, or putting in more action

For what it was...

As you stated, it was an animation test, so I reviewed it as such. The cycles are smooth and look good. The only reason I docked a point was for his turning around: from what I've seen elsewhere in the clip I know you can do something better than that.

Good work! I'd like to see a full animation with some sound.

People find this review helpful!
ThomasNoppers responds:

Thanks, I also really really hate the turnaround animation! It kind of looks like a bug.

Click on an icon to vote on this!

Credits & Info

2.44 / 5.00

Jun 22, 2009
9:46 PM EDT
More Movies