At least I'm a winner here >:)
I think that it's well constructed and that there is room for improvement - a voice actor stating the names of the users when you click on the links to each award. Though this could prove difficult with Most Underrated, it could be solved by having 2 pages for that. One linking to Me and the other to Timmy. Whether or not this is displayed on the front page would be entirely up to you.
A good selection of music from the Audio Portal, I can certainly see this becoming a regular occurrence in the portal, judging by how popular the whole concept of awarding people has become over the past few years.
[Review Request Club]