I enjoyed this, and to me that's all that matters.
I rate based on my experience. I don't bother trying to be 'subjective' or trying to rate how much work you put in or whether or not someone else would enjoy this flash.
When I review stuff on NG, I consider it a little dialogue between me and the author and all that matters is my experience and how i personally percieved the flash.
The title alone had me smiling. I paused for a moment, considered the hilarity of a godzilla too sad to stomp on buildings and readied myself. Whilst watching it for the first time, I pretty much just chuckled and chortled my way through it - the underwater dialogue is a particular favourite for me.
The happy tune was well picked, though I wasn't too keen on the techno aspect of the sad one.
I felt the graphics were fairly sloppy. I'm gonna assume you were actually trying to make them look decent and give a few pointers.
- The growing arm? It looks terrible. That made me unsure if you were going for a 'it's so bad it's good' quality or not. Seriously - the stretching arm to pick up the guy or push the building just looks ridiculous. Instead, he could've headbutted the building, or ran over to the guy, flicked him with his tail into his mouth.
- Don't stick to the swatches. Use the colour sliders (set to HSB) to get a nicer blue for a sky, a green that doesn't look so garish for the grass and so on.
Actually... given the mispellings and stuff, I'm gonna assume this was intentionally sloppy. But you know what? It didn't detract from the humour.
I enjoyed this, and to me that's all that matters.
- Review Request Club -