I've been watching the series since the very beginning. It's plainly awesome. Lots of anime chars I like and lots of randomness which I also like :D
9 for graphics is just because you made Gatsu have a real left hand while he had a false one.
9 for style cause you spell it Gutts instead of Gatsu :D It's read Gutts indeed but it's not spelled that way, anyway, it's just for the fun of it (I mean the rating for style and grafix. I just love Gatsu :P )
And also for putting all that random chipmunk bull in the beginning... it sucked man...
10s Overall from me and plz continue the story :D