I'd say Alan's was the better.
I didn't really feel Pinnicle's meant anything to be honest, it was a little boring :S
But Alan's was done really well, I loved the style of graphics, and the way it was set out. (Which was quite great really).
You don't except something like that to be a love story, and it's like a "suprise ending" if you will.. To find it's actually about the leaves, which does make sense, if you look back on it.
Pinncales was cool and all, Well.I didn't really like it but I couldn't of done neary as good.
Great work Alan :)
pinnicle-not too great, alan-deep.
Pinnicle's wasn't too funny or well animated, but Alan's had a great style, and... a love story shown by leaves - brilliant.
2 diff styles
Yo, its wrong to compare these two movies to each other because they are two completely different movies. Alanthebox's movie was deep and metaphoricle and Pinnicle's was based on humor. Pinnicle's movie shouldn't be judged on metaphorical stuff anymore than Alanthebox's movie should be judged on humor.
So there are only 9 contestants?!Awww,that sucks,i was looking forward to more of these...
There have only been 6 so far though.3 more...or?
What happened to the other 3?
I have to write a review
because I cannot respond to reviews because I am not the one who submitted this movie.
First of all, this wasn't a competition between AlantheBOX and myself so I don't understand why people are saying they are voting for him or for me. I think its unfair to compare my movie to AlantheBox's as if we were competing. We have completely different styles. These collaborations are supposed to be cooperation, not competition.
To respond to xjokerx, heaven forbid mindless violence on NG! It wasn't even senseless because it was leading up to the punchline, not just random violence. And yes I did base this movie off an old joke I had heard, I didn't think it was tired. As for storylines, check all my other movies. This was supposed to be a short and I didn't bother coming up with a complex plot. Characters? I have 10 original copyrighted characters portrayed on my site.
And so no one thinks i'm giving all 10's to myself, i'm giving them to alanthebox.