NG Time Trial Challenge B

Share Collapse

Author Comments

as quoted from Mr. Luis:
"This series consists of putting together a variety of ng artists at different skill levels and styles and having them work within tight deadlines. It wasnt really a competition but more a challenge to yourself to get something done within the short time. There were 9 entries total and in order to get everyone crammed into it we split it into 2 groups."

with that said, i give you group B! (group B was supposed to include more authors, but we experienced some technical difficulties)


1st one bad, 2nd one good

'the suggestion box', complete nonsense, not even funnyand i like stupid humour but that was just moronic, the animation was poor and the message from the suggestion box wasn't a suggestion but a question.
this collaboration was redeemed by 'leaves (a love story)', good animation, geed plot and an overall appealing style.
This collaboration is a good example of what can go wrong and what can go right in a timetrial.
'they said if i'd do the suggestion box they'll give me oreo's' pitiful.


... the first movie was pretty funny, the Batman thing was hilarious. I guess catnip squirrels are much better than catnip mice.

The second movie was vary different from the first. It was quite sad how the leaves were seperated at the end. Very nice artwork, I liked the style.

Congrats to the both of you on the great collab.


I thought leaves was a very good animation. I have never really liked Pinnacle and probably never will. Suggestion box did not help either.

Original...A love story about leaves...

qwerty...Catnip wasn't that funny...

My Favorite Titme Trial Ever.

AlantheBOX is an icon. Pinnacle... Is new to me, but he obviously has a successful series going for him. I just think it wasn't really fair to post these to movies together at the same time without any other movies of a different type, as most people were biased towards Alan's, simply because his was "deep." Even I was thinking Alan's was better, but only because there wasn't another contemporary piece to compare. But Alan wouldn't have been the only one who'd benefit, as Pinnacle's would've gotten more positive responses had his cartoon been submitted alongside another cartoon serial. A truly excellent concept, but it seems the organizational factor wasn't too thought out.

Click on an icon to vote on this!

Credits & Info

3.84 / 5.00

Feb 8, 2004
12:43 PM EST
  • Daily 4th Place February 9, 2004