00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

B0ss3 just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018

14,274 Views | 336 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:21:22


Welcome to the Newgrounds Underdogs’ Audio Contest Knock-out Round Thread 2018! :D If you want some background on why the NGUAC is so awesome, click HERE.

What’s a Knock-out Round?

The next stage of this 3-stage competition! Half of the original competitors from each group were accepted into the Knock-out Round, rounded down according to group membership and then rounded up if there were ties. The new group membership totals may be unequal as a result of ties, rounding, and disqualifications.

Speaking of disqualifications, we’re officially dismissing @GearWax from the competition, whose track used original content from a videogame soundtrack, and @ParabolicX, whose vocal samples unfairly compromised the originality of his track (and also may have violated NG audio guidelines). They were both warned of their impending dismissals at least several hours in advance.

So...what now?

The remaining competitors have until Sunday, August 5th at 11:59 pm EDT to submit a completely original track (i.e., made from scratch for the competition) to this thread. You couldn't have started working on this piece until NOW, as per the rules. If we find evidence of you having done so, you will be automatically disqualified. Please read all of the rules if you haven’t already.

There will be NO remixes, re-makes, mash-ups, covers, arrangements, or anything like that for this round. Your piece really has to be COMPLETELY original. It’s a good idea to clearly state what you used to make your track - which sounds are from VSTs/plugins, which ones you recorded yourself, and which ones are from downloaded sample libraries. NO COPYRIGHTED SAMPLES ARE ALLOWED. If you don’t know where a sample originates from, please don’t use it. This copyright policy is also clarified in the NG Audio Portal guidelines.

The eight strongest competitors from each group will be announced by Monday, August 1st. Then, those people will face each other in an epic finale!

Hmm...I didn’t get a very good score. I should probably make an ass of myself now.

NO! The judges (@ADR3-N, @Bosa, @EndKashika, @Frootza, @Jacob, @Kwing, @LunacyEcho, @Midimachine, @Random-Storykeeper, @SleepFacingWest, @Spadezer, and myself) worked really hard to deliver these scores on time, so please be patient and respectful with them. If you didn't make it into this round, please don't complain. Simply PM your respective judges if you have any questions or concerns, making sure to keep your tone friendly and not accusing. Your judge(s) might even be willing to leave you some reviews with specific feedback if you request it. Huge props to @ADR3-N and @Kwing, who did so already without anyone asking.

Anything else I should know?

The results will be posted in a separate forum post in a couple of minutes. After that, the specific scores given by each judge will also be released publicly in the thread.

Congratulations to all of the competitors for their hard work. There were some utterly fantastic submissions this year, and my favorites list has exploded over the past couple of weeks. That said, the toughest part of the competition is upon us! You may now begin working on your Knock-out Round tracks, everyone. Good luck!


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

For clarity purposes, here’s a list of competitors who DID NOT make it into the Knock-out Round. Better luck next time, guys!

@CrisTheGamer @VecodeX @BeeFef @Testuser472 @Spcialist @LordJabeebus @Naval76 @Akaruhime @MrCoolisimo @Alphysans @Nicfart646 @Animaniac333 @IndustryStandard @12HarmonicChaos @JAXXN @Johnnyq1233 @Alyctro @SpinBowNonOfficial @Gawne @Kbenitezlugo13 @ArachnidPlaysMusic @Packtion @SentientZero @DJTECKIE @Yeelp @GobBageEata @GALICROSS @EXplosion007 @Lofiskyline @Gonahens78 @ShockblastDeluxe @Epicamente-PACKman @K0TiC @8LayneTech8 @Calicrazedbeats @Arkinefed @Csukskos @Beluga-of-Time @Zodiax @ET16 @ConceptSama @FLASHYANIMATION @Funkmeisterfish @MrSmash64 @Kassich @D-Chain @SapkyRides @Bertn1991 @5TanLey @SoulSecure @AndoGDTunes @Canonblade @Dj-Gonzo @Slintas @DreyLand @HJFod @Nietzlaw @ELEPS44 @Watermusic34 @FlashFyre @Namice @Deshiel @TenodiBoris @Advertise-Play @Ti-on-suxandrox @NGKFlower @ZeroDigitZ @Sapoman @AlxEllis @K-oztron @ORI-TAGGART @Cimba @OiPriPri @Teodorattt @Munguia @Aelkamal @Katnip18 @RobinvanDommelen @SuperKidVN @Tetrahedrix @Ultimatepalmtree3 @ColorsCrimsonTears @Googlebugger @J-XVII @Malmon @Shabbyjazz @TheNeroExpress @CreeperX3sssBOOM @DarkProject16 @ElderlyKite @LavaRift @Noiseman @Novent-Music @Walpang @AsgoreD @Djn3utral123r @DustifiedGD @Geonb @JasLand @Connorhawke @Skandor @TheB34R @Ardakio2 @BBouthillette @CodebreakerS @LastyGhost @MattHatterXYZ @Johntheexile @MakutaMiner @Jeffbeard
@RickyCroci @FairydustOfficial @Hedrix @Cathatmusic @Unkindead @Charliux210123 @GruntVonVeizatun @Jmagnum @EnnardPlay @5dollar @LTGuitarist @Stapless @VarsityCreations @Sylux03 @DesoPL @Samfish + @Likwify @SirKoto51 @Zechnition @DarkHorseOrchestra @ElMarianz @Adhenoid @SlaughterClub @Xyhthisdi1987 @GDOP @Magnum13 @Jupitrean @Dowon @Coolasp1e @Phlex77 @SkullPioneer @Nathan-Hassall @Djresset @Belthagor @Death2go @GeometryDashMau5Kids @Flashmakeit


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:26:39


Scores by judge incoming:

UNDERDOGS (1/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:27:11


UNDERDOGS (2/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:27:35


PROF AMs (1/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:28:03


PROF AMs (2/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

AAJs (1/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

AAJs (2/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

ALL-STARS (1/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

ALL-STARS (2/2)

N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018


"Time's fun when you're having flies." ~Kermit the Frog

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:30:10


At 7/23/18 03:23 AM, TaintedLogic wrote: For clarity purposes, here’s a list of competitors who DID NOT make it into the Knock-out Round. Better luck next time, guys!

Eh... oh well ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. I'm just happy I got the chance to participate again, good luck to everyone who did make it ;)!


BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:34:09


Top in my category??? No way!! Freaking out right now lmao. Congrats to everyone else who made it!!

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:34:33


coolio. i should prolly get started then

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:34:37


welp, there's always next year.


if you want some bass of mine click here https://testuser472.newgrounds.com/audio

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:48:10


Great work, everyone!

I'd like to formally invite anyone who participated in my category (Above Average Joes) to request a review with a detailed analysis of their track. I am under the impression (please do not quote me, I'd hate to brew false hope) that we will be taking time to give everyone proper feedback, but not every judge will be writing on every piece - so I want to extend myself to anyone curious about my score in particular.

Good luck to those competing in the Knock-out Round!
And to those who didn't quite make the cut, please keep making music. There was something to enjoy in every track that I listened to, and I implore you to continue to hone your skills, and to enjoy every moment you spend making mellifluous noise.


BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 03:51:27


At 7/23/18 03:23 AM, TaintedLogic wrote: For clarity purposes, here’s a list of competitors who DID NOT make it into the Knock-out Round. Better luck next time, guys!

haha, failed once again


Hello thar ;)

BBS Signature

I know this contest had this set format for years, but since next round has much less submissions, can i suggest a bigger number of judges for next round with a dropout of the lowest score? I think it would benefit a lot to stabilize score.

2 extra judges, with the lowest score being removed would help out to stabilize the extreme deviation between a 3 judge votation @TaintedLogic, specially since @Bosa and @EndKashika had the highest one between all the judges, which is bound to happen to such a diverse competition.


Ow, 6th place this time. Nice.
Glad to see something improved over the year.

Fingers crossed to everyone in this round!


~ Jessie

✨ENFP | 🎵 Epic Music Composer for: ACE/Old Chicago/OddTodd |🎬 Film Student | Status : Study Mode!

Visit My Official Portfolio!

BBS Signature

Just a note here, anyone not in my category, feel free to request a review of your piece in the meantime.

At 7/23/18 04:18 AM, NyxTheShield wrote: 2 extra judges, with the lowest score being removed would help out to stabilize the extreme deviation between a 3 judge votation @TaintedLogic, specially since @Bosa and @EndKashika had the highest one between all the judges, which is bound to happen to such a diverse competition.

This will affect scoring. Nobody wants their opinion deleted. Human nature. No matter how you quantify it, unless none of the judges are told the lowest or highest score will be deleted (which we just telegraphed), the end result is going to be the judges consciously or subconsciously thinking about which scores will and will not go, not just giving their honest assessment. Even taking the median score could result in this.

The exception would be blindfolding the judges. Even so, I still don't like the idea that, if I had a serious problem with some elements in a track and rated lower than the other judges on the panel as a result, it'd be like I just walked out of the room. I think the current scoring method is fine.

I do wish there were one more judge, but first round was a whopper -- bigger than AIM by about 23 pieces, with a shorter time frame to judge -- and that's just the bracket I chose. Had a great time going through all the pieces. Was a real journey!


Your source for monthly music producer freebies here // Take My Cymbals // ALL my big sample projects, FREE

I do professional audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT and X! If you got music, I'll playlist you!

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 06:29:39


At 7/23/18 06:26 AM, ADR3-N wrote: This will affect scoring. Nobody wants their opinion deleted. Human nature. No matter how you quantify it, unless none of the judges are told the lowest or highest score will be deleted (which we just telegraphed), the end result is going to be the judges consciously or subconsciously thinking about which scores will and will not go, not just giving their honest assessment. Even taking the median score could result in this.
.

Just suggesting a solution, there are a lot of methods to help the issue. An extra judge would certainly help a lot.


At 7/23/18 06:29 AM, NyxTheShield wrote: Just suggesting a solution, there are a lot of methods to help the issue. An extra judge would certainly help a lot.

Hey, we good fam. Just my two cents. *insert ok-hand emoji*

I think one more judge per category, or judges spanning more than one category would be more convenient. In the drop-score scenario not only would we need to find 2 more judges per category last minute and explain to them "O hey, one of y'all is gonna get Game of Thrones'd every song LOL," but it'd just be inconvenient to go into each Google Sheets cell and remove a variable by hand for the averages. The same system with an added column would work just as smooth as before.

I actually was unsure if we should rate integers or decimals. I feel like decimals would be a better tie-breaker, and I see that other judges have been rating with .5's and 25's, whereas my bracket did not for some reason. @TaintedLogic?


Your source for monthly music producer freebies here // Take My Cymbals // ALL my big sample projects, FREE

I do professional audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT and X! If you got music, I'll playlist you!

BBS Signature

I MADE IT IN!!!! :D

Might not make it into the knock-out round, but it still means a lot that I made it in NGUAC! :D

(I need to make more cinematic music more often! ;P)

...AND TO CONGRATULATE A FEW OTHER PEOPLE:

@BlueOceans Congrats on making it in! :D
@Ryzmik @Zophar OH WOW! Two other familiar yet unknown faces... in the All-Star NGUAC! :O
@Kirefyx A very close and familiar face to me, good luck in the knock-out round! :D


BBS Signature

Whoah. I've got a good submission though. Hhmm maybe it's not my year. GGWP.


- Sylux

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 07:39:11


ah my first time in the NGUAC! not really sure how it all works but it's a pleasure to be here :)


BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 07:54:15


As other judges have already mentioned, we appreciated your hard work getting into this contest, and I will not be opposed to doing more in-depth reviews for the Above-Average-Joe's. I've taken the liberty to leave a couple comments here and there where I felt inspired to do so, but I will not be opposed to be doing more comments

As a disclaimer, I'll be doing NGADM reviews this week so I may not be too prompt in getting a review to you, but I will not ignore PM's


DM me if you want a review!

BBS Signature

Response to N G U A C Knock-out Round 2018 2018-07-23 08:12:21


Damn, well, awesome...


cereal :з

BBS Signature