00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme
Upgrade Your Account!

Newgrounds made a lot of infrastructure upgrades this month and needs your help!

Become a Supporter for just $3 a month or $25 for the year.

Shout out to @travsaus for megaphone tankman!

Official "Review for Review" Thread

292,054 Views | 4,049 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Thanks to Blacklawn for the idea. Go ahead and favorite him to show the love. ;) Have a look at the old thread here.

Welcome to the Review for Review (R4R) thread!

What is this place? You may call it a rip off of the Review Request Club, or just a shameless self promotion advertisement thread. However, this thread GUARANTEES a review on your song. That's why it is called the R4R thread.

How does the R4R thread work then? Basically, you HAVE to review ANY song that has been linked in this thread BEFORE you can post a link to what ever song you want to be reviewed

------------------

To prevent any unwanted reviews on old songs please link a song you WANT to be reviewed on.
Note: You can only link one song per review.

To make things even more interesting: Feel free to post a link that isn't your song that you want to be reviewed.

When you review, put a tag of something like "R4R" at the end so that we can gain more traffic in this thread.

------------------

Motivate the community!

What can I do to help?

- First thing you can do is by leaving constructive reviews. Throw a couple points that you liked, what you disliked, and what could be improved on. All of this can be done in a paragraph.

- Add artists to your favorites! People love seeing high number of fans/views on their music.

- Keep checking up on this thread. The original thread gained 70 posts in a single day! That is quite a lot for a slow running Audio Forum.

------------------

Point System

I will be adding a point system to this thread. Basically it'll be something similar to what the Review Request Club does. I and perhaps a couple other folks will count up reviews people have written from the start of this thread and update it weekly.

Everybody loves stats!

For Example

User | Reviews | Rank | # of places moved up or down from previews week.
Sequenced | 001 | 1 | +0 |

I will be updating this every Sunday night.

------------------

Rules

- Please do your best to not spam reviews and post your songs. THIS MEANS NO ONE-LINER REVIEWS. Everyone wants exposure. Keep it to a couple per week, depending on how fast this thread grows. Remember folks, use your common sense. ;)

- If you feel a review is unfair or quite harsh, DO NOT vent in this thread. PM the reviewer if you have a problem and try to clear things out. If that doesn't work, send the issue to one of the audio mods in a PM and then we'll fix the problem and make everyone happy.

- If you post a song without reviewing someone else's, you will be given a warning. Same thing for one-liners. If you keep doing this on a consistent basis, THERE WILL BE CONSEQUENCES.

- Most important rule of all, have fun! Just being apart of the old thread made me feel like the community is back to the way it was years ago where everybody loved to review and get reviews back. This will really help new users feel welcomed and finally has a way to reach out to people without the fear of some nerdy prick linking the Audio Advertisement Thread. ;)

------------------

This took me an hour to write up. Time for lunch!

lel

BBS Signature

lel

BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 11:45:07


Since bassfiddlejones posted this song before the lock and edit, I'd left a review:

  • Unpublished Submission

And if anyone could critique me on this one, that'd be great :)

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 12:02:42


Pretty spacy! (Almost like I felt I was high at some point).

And mine. :)

  • Unpublished Submission


CentralComposers TEMP - Cinematic, Hybrid and Soundtrack Sample libraries.

Sound Designer and Audio Engine Programmer.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 12:10:38


I left a review for this song :

  • Unpublished Submission

This is what I would liked review:

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 12:29:26


At 6/20/13 12:10 PM, TheShowGuy wrote: I left a review for this song :
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/514730
This is what I would liked review:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/539994

I left a review for your song.
I would like this song reviewed.

  • Unpublished Submission

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 12:33:57


I'm sorry, but it seems like you just hijacked Blacklawn's thread for the sake of integrating that point system everyone in the previous thread told you was a bad idea.

In any case, it's still a good idea of a thread, so I'll participate nonetheless.

Reviewed this:

  • Unpublished Submission

I'd like this to be reviewed:

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 12:46:30


I would first like to say how much I love everybody updated this thread in such quick succession, because then I felt obligated to review everyone, as the minute I finished a review, someone else posted in this thread hahahahahaha.

So I reviewed all these (forgot the R4R tag until halfway through):

And here's something of mine:


BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 13:08:39


Hey, it's great to see my original idea achieved something!

By the was. a constant problem in the old thread was that people would get ninja'd by accident and would lose their opportunity to get reviewed with that post, so changing the mandatory "review from the poster immediately above" prevents that, but I still think it would be interesting if the mandatory reviews were restricted to recent posts, to ensure that recent posters wouldn't get overlooked.

This is the song I reviewed now:

I'd like some thoughts on this:

  • Unpublished Submission

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 16:15:31


i reviewed this magic song :D

Song

if you are not busy check out mine :)

My Song

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 22:46:43


At 6/20/13 04:15 PM, MrKle1n wrote: i reviewed this magic song :D
My Song

I reviewed your song.

This isn't my song, but its very good

  • Unpublished Submission

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-20 23:16:18


reviewed this:

  • Unpublished Submission

want a review or feedback on this :)


Latest track :

Distance


p.s. i am gay

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-21 00:09:57


the top two are IOUs from the original thread, btw.


p.s. i am gay

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-21 07:12:10


Reviewed, damn forgot to say I would have like to have heard some mechanical pistons pumping.

  • Unpublished Submission

I would like reviewed, any of my work, as it's all pretty recent :)


BBS Signature

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-21 10:50:58


At 6/21/13 07:12 AM, ulfusNG wrote: Reviewed, damn forgot to say I would have like to have heard some mechanical pistons pumping.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/469765
I would like reviewed, any of my work, as it's all pretty recent :)

Reviewed this:

And I made an extended version of Spiralomorph, with drums and stuff. It's definitely NOT for everyone, but, by all means, give it a listen:

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-21 19:00:59



CentralComposers TEMP - Cinematic, Hybrid and Soundtrack Sample libraries.

Sound Designer and Audio Engine Programmer.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-21 21:12:38


I reviewed this short but very nice sounding piece : )

  • Unpublished Submission

This is my latest post : ) Enjoy

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-22 23:17:04


Reviewed:

  • Unpublished Submission

This is the song I've just finished:

  • Unpublished Submission


: What? No I won't level up, I like my watergun.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 06:21:49


I reviewed this:

Was an excellent running, videogame track, I recommend it for everyone who liked that old PSONE game tracks.

Also be free to review anything you like ;)

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 07:36:25


I gave this track some reviewin' love.

  • Unpublished Submission

Any of my tracks from 2011 on are fair game. Take a look, take a review.


Need some music for a flash or game? Check it out. If none of this works send me a PM, I'm taking requests.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 08:45:13


At 6/23/13 07:36 AM, Gario wrote: I gave this track some reviewin' love.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/540350
Any of my tracks from 2011 on are fair game. Take a look, take a review.

person above you?

anyway i reviewed this:

someone should review this (although i don't really care lol):


p.s. i am gay

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 09:40:56


At 6/23/13 08:45 AM, midimachine wrote: black

I don't care which of my songs is reviewed.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 11:32:00


At 6/23/13 08:45 AM, midimachine wrote: person above you?

My apologies, I had the window open for a while and had responses above since I posted. Refresh is my friend, I suppose.

Anyhoo, here's a review of this track.

Anything from my 2011-on list is still good.


Need some music for a flash or game? Check it out. If none of this works send me a PM, I'm taking requests.

Response to Official "Review for Review" Thread 2013-06-23 12:08:26


At 6/23/13 11:32 AM, Gario wrote: Anything from my 2011-on list is still good.

You make awesome music.

  • Unpublished Submission

Could somebody drop me a review on this:

  • Unpublished Submission