Indulge me a moment as I speak, in general terms, on the shape of things at present. Newgrounds has had the great fortune of serving as a launch venue for some great professional artists and programmers, helping to further quite a few indie endeavors. This has been a great boon for the site, but as it stands the large majority of contributors to Newgrounds do so as a hobby.
The sense of professionalism, however, is pervasive, serving as a lense through which the quality of contributions are judged. There is a clear sense of what is good and what is bad and the admins of the site do a great job of showcasing the former. In this sense, Newgrounds has great utility to serious and talented creators. The Newgrounds community enhances this utility by providing a breeding ground; a location where aspiring creators find encouragement, critique, and comraderie.
I've realized that, as a fairly new sector of Newgrounds, this forum, and potential portal, dedicated to writing has some growing to do. Moreover, this community needs to mature; develop expectations. Where the visual and audio segments succeed is in the establishment of clearly defined standards. There is plenty of room for experimentation, but the community, as a whole, is able to identify what works, what doesn't, and they can put that to words (or numbers, as the case may be). Granted these other forms have a healthy backing, as well as a portal, but the idea remains. If we're able to garner the attention required to warrant a portal
Now here's an anecdote: I remember when Fancy Pants Adventures was just an idea, and Brad Bourne was still young, and impressionable. This was back in 2004 when I was one of the Flash Forum regulars. He came to the forum looking for help with something or the other, and he was helped, plain and simple. The forum helped him when he needed it, and he has since launched himself a healthy career. Brad went from hobby to profession, and in some part, Newgrounds (and the Flash forum) contributed to that.
Essay out of the way, I am proposing the following: an organization of the flash forum, the development of an ad hoc portal that will not only shape the development of the forum, but encourage all individuals regardless of their aims. As it stands, no one is going to garner much attention posting on a forum. Steps have been made to try to bring more attention to those who deserve it. That was an awesome, organic tangent; thank you, Ekublai. But we need to take it a step further. We need to help everyone understand the expectations of this forum. In addition to Ekublai's Highlights thread, we need a how-to manual that will allow users who don't know the craft to learn the jargon and how to use it. We need strong examples of what the acceptable level of quality is, and we need to parade it. With technical knowledge, expectations on quality, and a means to elevate those who contribute the most, I feel we'll take great strides toward steadying this forum's turbulent progress, and assuring the creation of the Lit portal.
Some things we can do:
- Use the Review thread in my signature as it's meant to be used. This means in addition to submitting your work to the forum, take the time to review somebody else's. Once done, update the review thread and I guarantee, from myself or the pool of critics I'll be gathering, you will receive a clear, and useful critique to your piece.
- Reward the critics! Relative new comer mzhinski, as an example, has provided more critique recently than even myself. Albeit biting, his critique is often clear and to the point. I've only seen maybe two or three threads from him. This type of behavior is definitely worth some sort of appreciation. It's selfless, and we need more of that especially from the non-regulars.
- Reward the writers too! I've seen some pretty bad writing in this forum, so it makes it that much more enjoyable when I find something good. Ekublai's highlights thread aims to reward these efforts, but I think we need to go further than that. I would love to institute our own contests. For example, we were left out of this past Robot Day. I actually started a really great short story based off of my submission. There is real value in participating in these events and the only way that'll happen is if we facilitate it. As some of you may know, the last them writers were included, the judges weren't necessarily well versed in literary critique which resulted in a poor outcome. Let's take matters into our own hands.
- Probably most important of all, reward the readers! Reading is an awefully passive activity, requiring stimulation to come from the imagination. This is as opposed to the very aggresive, very engrossing forms of media Newgrounds features. Choosing to read should always be rewarded, and this is especially true. The trouble with this is: there is no real way to determine who is reading. This is an item that would make a pretty good discussion piece.
- Form a writing group. I can't be the only writer here who aims to write professionally. I think the average user writes as a hobby, but there is a lot to be gained when aspiring professionals come together. There is an elevated sense of severity, I feel, that inspires confidence in the participants. There's also a trust, a "we're in the trenches together, so maybe we should stick together," that comes with these types of groups. I, for one, would value such a group. As it stands, it's becoming increasingly difficult appropriating time for the forum, and becoming seriously involved, because my interests are elsewhere. I'm still invested in the success of this community (thus, this post), but realistically, I don't have the time to put into action a lot of these ideas simply because I cannot justify to myself the investment in time.
What's the consensus?