At 4/3/12 06:39 PM, BrokenDeck wrote:
This sort of thing belongs more in the Club and Crew Forum, whereas the Audio forum is more for the discussion of music PRODUCTION.
Just a friendly tip ;)
Really? I can move it, but I've also seen the music contests posted here as well.
As long as we're still in the planning stage, I can at least answer the questions posted before I start something presentable, that way we can communicate via PM and hash things out that way.
1. I believe we DO need two separate groups, because otherwise someone would pick a song they would want to cover anyway, though a rule can be instituted that you can't cover a song that you picked. Plus it's done by the A.V. Club AND its readers, so I think the NG public at large should have a say in it. Collectively, the 25 artists could come up with 3-ish songs to put into the mix, but that's it.
2. For AVUC, the songs come first, then they send the list out to anyone interested. Sometimes an artist is unable to do it, but that's because they have to fly to Chicago and play live. Since
A. You don't have to play the song live (if you don't want to) and
B. You don't have to travel anywhere, this might change things.
3. I do want to participate, but I'll voulenteer to go last.