00:00
00:00

Review Request Club

571,018 Views | 9,880 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-15 02:48:34


i love this thread and i would like to join. Though i wont be keeping track of my points if thats cool. Alos i wont be doing a ton of reviewing because my computer takes soo long to load everything from the movie to just opening up the review tab... But ill do what i can.

Also i was wondering if you guys could review my two movies. Its a series. I have part 1 & 2, and i would love feedback on what to improve on, and what to keep the same for part three since i will began working on it here soon.

It is a sprite series about the Mario Brothers and many other characters from the old NES system.

Part 1

Part 2

Anyways thanks, and also ill be on vacation in aug for 2 weeks so if the reviews come then, and you dont see a reponse... its cause im not home, but i assure you ill respond to em all.


touchin 101

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-16 12:11:54


hey guys, Another song i would like a review or 2 for please.


I Stopped A Rape!!!

" If music is an art, let your car be the canvas, "

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-16 12:24:07


At 7/13/09 12:53 PM, Sonofkirk wrote:

Thanks for the update Sinofkirk.

My bad, I was dealing with other stuff while doing the udpate,

update*

xD

as consequence I made major errors. First the list was showing the old Total Stats as Haggard pointed out and this is actually the fourth update, not the fifth.

Don't worry about the mistake. You know we really appreciate the update even if it has a couple of mistakes in it.


And to answer your question Haggard, Fro requested reviews on several of his movies as a consequence his "Could have" stat is lower than yours. So he can have a higher completion ratio than you and be below you on the list.

NO THATS NOT HOW IT WORKS!

Because I had less chances to get points I should actually be above him. You dirty little bastard. This is what Sonofkirk told me over AIM. (And I quote)

I put Haggard ahead of you because I think he's cooler then you.


Hopefully I fixed everything, I'm PMing a mod to delete the mistaken post and possibly the posts below the update. Here are the requests to be done for next update, on Sunday 19th.

They didn't delete it? I guess it's not a big deal as long as nobody gets confused.


Flash Requests (6)

A good round of flashes this time around. I have finished all of them and I have to say they were all pretty good.

Audio Requests (11)

Still have more than half of these to do. I was very busy, but I think I can find the time to finish them either tonight or tomorrow sometime. Some good audio this time around too!

Art Requests (5)

My favorite author was in there. :P

I think I'm getting better at art reviews. I hope I am at least.

04 ) 405 | 62 / 62 | 100.00% || 106 | 16 / 16 | 100.00% Frocky52

Hmm, Number 3 you mean. Keeping up my 100% streak as long as I can. Someone recently deleted some of their audio as I lost 6 reviews. We should make it a rule that you can't request a review here if your going to delete your submission down the road.

*New To the List: AnalPenguinFarming

Welcome my Anal friend.

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Haggard, Fro, Insanimation and JKMonkey. MultiCaminefan, you missed the review for the spotlighted submission: Planet Nuke, sorry.

Perhaps it's better to put the spotlight submission in with the regular ones along with you recommended it like you did this time around.

Ahem, the usual suspects as Coop would say. A couple of ones that I'm still not used to seeing get 100% yet though.

At 7/13/09 09:16 AM, Sonofkirk wrote: Just because Fro won't ever stop crying:

03 ) 405 | 46 / 46 | 100.00% || 106 | 16 / 16 | 100.00% Frogay52
04 ) 405 | 46 / 51 | 092.54% || 106 | 16 / 16 | 100.00% Haggard

Though, I like you more than him, Haggard.

You son of a bitch.

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-16 16:50:18


Love this thread! Surprised all I have to do is post a link. This song I worked on for 11 hours or so. All day, two days.

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-16 17:02:58


At 7/16/09 12:24 PM, Fro wrote: NO THATS NOT HOW IT WORKS!

Because I had less chances to get points I should actually be above him. You dirty little bastard. This is what Sonofkirk told me over AIM. (And I quote)

I put Haggard ahead of you because I think he's cooler then you.

That's because "Haggard" sounds much cooler than "Fro" (or "Corky52" for that matter). :P

On Topic: Wow, still have a lot of requests to do, but I have been very busy. I have to examns next week. :/


Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-16 23:46:03


Thanks for the update, Sonofkirk. You're doing a great job here, keep it up!

At 7/13/09 12:53 PM, Sonofkirk wrote: 14 ) 039 | 05 / 49 | 010.20% || 009 | 01 / 16 | 006.25% Metal-Therapy

Okay, I managed to do 1 last week. XD Writing reivews has always been very time consuming for me and my life is just too messed up right now to have that time available. Still, I will try to write at least 1 per week. -That should be more than manageable for me.

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Haggard, Fro, Insanimation and JKMonkey.

Good job, guys. Coop, Haggard and Corky, you guys never fail to impress! :D


.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-17 05:51:14


At 7/16/09 12:24 PM, Fro wrote: Because I had less chances to get points I should actually be above him. You dirty little bastard. This is what Sonofkirk told me over AIM. (And I quote)
I put Haggard ahead of you because I think he's cooler then you.

Haha I didn't say that, I said "I put Haggard ahead of you because he is cooler THAN you". You little grammar nazi bastard. How many times have I corrected you about that on AIM? Seriously go back to school, you need it ;P.

Hmm, Number 3 you mean. Keeping up my 100% streak as long as I can. Someone recently deleted some of their audio as I lost 6 reviews. We should make it a rule that you can't request a review here if your going to delete your submission down the road.

Actually, audio artists don't know if they are going to delete their submission. What happens most of time is that they delete a track because they just submitted a better version of it with some tweaking or they added vocals or whatever.

You son of a bitch.

adsfasdfasdfasdf :D

At 7/16/09 11:46 PM, Metal-Therapy wrote: Okay, I managed to do 1 last week. XD Writing reivews has always been very time consuming for me and my life is just too messed up right now to have that time available. Still, I will try to write at least 1 per week. -That should be more than manageable for me.

Yeah, I feel the same for me, I just try to get one or two requests done per week but nothing more, it's way too long. When I audio review, I can spend more than an hour to write one - although I tend to write a bit shorter reviews for the RRC - so I couldn't do much more requests.

At 7/16/09 05:02 PM, Haggard wrote: That's because "Haggard" sounds much cooler than "Fro" (or "Corky52" for that matter). :P

Lol yeah, I wonder why he changed his username to Fro... Corky52 was acceptable but Fro... huh. :P.

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-17 13:01:26


Hay guys, I'm on a roll!

I'd like to submit my latest one, a tinted charcoal piece this time... pretty please? :D

http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/echor un/cliff-top-perch

Thanks to everyone who has reviewed my last one so far - I'll be catching up on the rest of the responses tonight. :)

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-17 19:31:36


You can tick mine off as done. Thanks again guys.

Oh... And... Uh... While you're at it...

I know this isn't the best of collabs, and half way through the sound DOES go out of sync, but it could use a bit of constructive criticism.


We had some good times, Newgrounds.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-17 21:57:08


Hey guys. Thanks for the review on my Joker pic. Got another for you ;D
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/virid is/quarter-face-collab


instagram.com/kumquat_cloud

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-18 09:49:56


Hello, guys! Can I ask you to review my last work? I'll be very grateful) It's here:

EvilScorpio - Fletus Caeli

I hope you like it)


New song: Twin Pulsar ||||| Recommended Flash: What Can Be Changed ||||| Habitat: Review Request Club

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-18 20:46:19


Hello,

I'm requesting a review for this.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/50 3814

I needed to resubmit, due to a serious problem that has now been fixed.
Thanks,
- Celx


Watch Shark Black HERE Watch CoolJaw HERE

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 00:55:28


I just want to say through this thread how thankful I am to all of you guys who reviewed my audio. I really appreciate the time and effort you put into them (although I regret flooding you guys with three of mine in the same week!).
Just don't give away those 9's and 10's so easily next time! (And there will be a next time.)
Thanks again!


Hey, I do audio. Check it out!

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 04:56:45


All review requests for the past week completed.

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 14:46:37


At 7/19/09 04:56 AM, MultiCanimefan wrote: All review requests for the past week completed.

^^ same here, might be the last time I'll be able to complete them all for a while

going on vacation next week

|"My dick was in the Guinness Boom of World Records... Then I left the library.|

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 14:52:25


At 7/19/09 02:46 PM, JKMonkey wrote:
At 7/19/09 04:56 AM, MultiCanimefan wrote:
going on vacation next week

Where are you headed?

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 15:06:04


At 7/19/09 02:52 PM, MultiCanimefan wrote:
At 7/19/09 02:46 PM, JKMonkey wrote:
At 7/19/09 04:56 AM, MultiCanimefan wrote:
going on vacation next week
Where are you headed?

Daytona Beach, Florida, i need to go to a nice beach with some blue water, the weather sucks here in Boston


|"My dick was in the Guinness Boom of World Records... Then I left the library.|

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 16:31:07


Well, I'm only doing this because Sonofkirk wants me too. I just hope Multicanimefan and JKMonkey don't catch up...


GOTPENMUSTFLASH!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-19 21:05:42


At 7/19/09 04:31 PM, Insanimation wrote: Well, I'm only doing this because Sonofkirk wants me too. I just hope Multicanimefan and JKMonkey don't catch up...
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/50 3308

^^ just did it, now I have all my reviews done


|"My dick was in the Guinness Boom of World Records... Then I left the library.|

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-20 14:11:30


Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-20 15:56:01


No update tonight as I've let some members know, I can't use my computer - I'm writing this with my sister's Mac. I've pulled half of the stats today so it'll save me time when I'll update the list, tomorrow.

I have no idea when I'll post the list tomorrow though, it'll be random. Also since I'm leaving for two weeks on Wenesday, there won't be an update next week. Sorry about all of that guys, real life happens to overtake NG life, sometimes.

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-20 20:55:33


At 7/20/09 03:56 PM, Sonofkirk wrote:
I have no idea when I'll post the list tomorrow though, it'll be random. Also since I'm leaving for two weeks on Wenesday, there won't be an update next week. Sorry about all of that guys, real life happens to overtake NG life, sometimes.

^^ no problem, thats actually good because I'll be on vacation next week as well and wont be able to do many reviews.


|"My dick was in the Guinness Boom of World Records... Then I left the library.|

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 01:53:34


http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/theth inwhale/pyscadellic-birds

Its an art image, I think it's really good but everyone rated it poorly and no one left a comment

please have a look I was thinking of having it as an album cover for my band :(

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 08:52:04


Hey there, here is finally the update after two days of passionate waiting :P. The week was very contrasted between members that completed all the requests and those who were almost inactive - myself for instance -.-

I re-implemented the "stars" system that used to be in the old thread, so we know who is inactive and for how long. If you think it should be modified it a bit - if you think we need to change the time of inactivity to get excluded from the list for example - let me know :).

I'm leaving on Wenesday for two weeks and I won't be able to update the list where I will be. I'll come back on Thursday 6th of August, so the list will be updated on Sunday 9th of August, that will make a lot of requests to complete for the update that will follow, so be ready.

Also note that whoever make fun of my current whistle status will get kicked out of the list next update ;). Here are the requests you'll have to complete for the next update, on Sunday 9th of August, that is.

Flash Requests (6)
My girl =] By ninetailedfoxdemon
Super Mario Invaded By sleeeeep
Super Mario Invaded pt.2 By sleeeeep
The ALL Sprites Collab By Nathan Stevenson (segaplaya)
The Shark Dossier By Celx R (Celx-Requin)
Spread His Wings By Insanimation

Audio Requests (10)
Closing Club By no name (mariomusicmaker1)
Drunken Singing By chrisG755
Nonascertainableness By JohnnyCellulose
Paradox (Bestial Remains) By Colt (Blackdoom13)
Tom Fulp, Share Your Chicks! By CountBoogie
-_ You Fucking Win _- By no name (mariomusicmaker1)
(SoD)-Eternal Arcade By statueofdiveo
Fletus Caeli By Alexander (EvilScorpio)
-Drifting- By Trevor Crookston (BlazingDragon)
State of Flux (ft. Bracksta) By jxl180

Art Requests (3)
Cliff Top Perch By EchoRun
Quarter Face Collab By Viridis
Pyscadellic Birds By David Neville (TheThinWhale)

Member's Update #5:
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]

01 ) 571 | 88 / 88 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Coop83
02 ) 547 | 84 / 84 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Fro
03 ) 547 | 84 / 89 | 094.38% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Haggard
04 ) 498 | 79 / 88 | 089.77% || 090 | 15 / 22 | 068.18% SCTE3
05 ) 440 | 67 / 67 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Insanimation
06 ) 400 | 62 / 89 | 069.66% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% MulticanimeFan
07 ) 383 | 59 / 59 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% JKMonkey
08 ) 173 | 29 / 89 | 032.58% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% milinko959 *
09 ) 139 | 21 / 71 | 029.58% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% Alfierulz **
10 ) 129 | 20 / 89 | 022.47% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% lmacow *
11 ) 069 | 11 / 38 | 028.95% || 030 | 05 / 22 | 022.73% AnalPenguinFarming
12 ) 062 | 10 / 59 | 016.95% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% EpicFail **
13 ) 060 | 08 / 89 | 008.99% || 003 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% Sonofkirk
14 ) 042 | 05 / 71 | 007.04% || 003 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% Metal-Therapy
15 ) 033 | 05 / 89 | 005.62% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% jew193 **
16 ) 032 | 05 / 57 | 008.77% || 006 | 01 / 21 | 004.76% blackcat2000
17 ) 023 | 04 / 71 | 005.63% || 000 | 00 / 22 | 000.00% Hiphopopotamus **

The stars indicate for how long the user has been inactive in this club. "Inactive" means, that user hasn't gained any points by reviewing OR by posting.
*: User has been inactive last week
**: User has been inactive for the last two weeks
***: User has been inactive for the last three weeks
****: User has been inactive for the last four weeks

If you are inactive for more than three weeks AND if your completion rate falls below 20%, OR if you are inactive for more than four weeks you are excluded from the list. You may rejoin this club, but your points will be lost.

Statistics:
*Requests this week: 22
Total Requests all time: 89
Review made this Week: 103
Average per member: 6.059
Average per request: 4.682

*New To the List: None
Leaving the List: None

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Fro, Haggard, Insanimation, MulticanimeFan and JKMonkey

Member's Update #4

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 09:14:18


At 7/21/09 08:52 AM, Sonofkirk wrote:

Thanks for the update Sonofkirk.

Hey there, here is finally the update after two days of passionate waiting :P. The week was very contrasted between members that completed all the requests and those who were almost inactive - myself for instance -.-

Yeah, thanks for making was wait. I don't know when real life is ever more important than updating this list for everyone. Jeeze what were you thinking. ;)


I re-implemented the "stars" system that used to be in the old thread, so we know who is inactive and for how long. If you think it should be modified it a bit - if you think we need to change the time of inactivity to get excluded from the list for example - let me know :).

I never had a problem with this. :P Yeah it's good though so we can see who is starting to become inactive and everything. I think it will work fine the way it is.


I'm leaving on Wenesday for two weeks and I won't be able to update the list where I will be. I'll come back on Thursday 6th of August, so the list will be updated on Sunday 9th of August, that will make a lot of requests to complete for the update that will follow, so be ready.

Yeah, we should be doing them as they are requested if we can so the load isn't as big. I will finally fall down below 100% going back to my dial up, but I'll try to get at least all the art reviews done as they don't have big file sizes. Any songs or flashes without big file sizes I might be able to review also.


Also note that whoever make fun of my current whistle status will get kicked out of the list next update ;). Here are the requests you'll have to complete for the next update, on Sunday 9th of August, that is.

Hmmmmmmmmm


Flash Requests (6)

Not a bad number. I seem to be losing more reviews then I write though. People need to stop deleting their movies.

Audio Requests (10)

Nice this will bump me up to the 800 audio review mark. That will be a nice milestone reached.

Art Requests (3)

I'll try to do these as soon as I'm done with my list. They don't take long to load. :P

01 ) 571 | 88 / 88 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Coop83

Can't you become a BBS mod or something so you find even last time to be able to write these reviews? ;)

02 ) 547 | 84 / 84 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Fro

Woah, from fourth to 2nd in one update. Now just if I wouldn't have requested some things I'd be right up there with Coop. Oh well, I rather get some more reviews then be ranked up higher on the list I guess.

03 ) 547 | 84 / 89 | 094.38% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Haggard

Tied for 2nd in a way.

04 ) 498 | 79 / 88 | 089.77% || 090 | 15 / 22 | 068.18% SCTE3

He kept telling me he's been busy. He also hasn't been on AIM in a long time. Perhaps he will find the time again someday.

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Fro, Haggard, Insanimation, MulticanimeFan and JKMonkey

This is what is starting to become the regular members now. You'd usually expect SCTE3 up here too, but other than that not bad at all.

lol where is the deity whistle?!?!?!

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 13:21:32


At 7/21/09 08:52 AM, Sonofkirk wrote: Hey there, here is finally the update after two days of passionate waiting :P.

YAY! It's finally here! Thanks, Sonofkirk!

I'm leaving on Wenesday for two weeks and I won't be able to update the list where I will be. I'll come back on Thursday 6th of August, so the list will be updated on Sunday 9th of August, that will make a lot of requests to complete for the update that will follow, so be ready.

Uh-oh....Never fear, I'll have my new Mac so it'll all be a bitt easier/harder..:/


Also note that whoever make fun of my current whistle status will get kicked out of the list next update ;). Here are the requests you'll have to complete for the next update, on Sunday 9th of August, that is.

HEY GUYS! NICO HAS A SI - Sorry. I'm just surprised that you've managed to get so high in such short time..


Flash Requests (6)
My girl =] By ninetailedfoxdemon
Super Mario Invaded By sleeeeep
Super Mario Invaded pt.2 By sleeeeep
The ALL Sprites Collab By Nathan Stevenson (segaplaya)
The Shark Dossier By Celx R (Celx-Requin)
Spread His Wings By Insanimation

That's not too bad, but the first one is an art submission.


Audio Requests (10)
Closing Club By no name (mariomusicmaker1)
Drunken Singing By chrisG755
Nonascertainableness By JohnnyCellulose
Paradox (Bestial Remains) By Colt (Blackdoom13)
Tom Fulp, Share Your Chicks! By CountBoogie
-_ You Fucking Win _- By no name (mariomusicmaker1)
(SoD)-Eternal Arcade By statueofdiveo
Fletus Caeli By Alexander (EvilScorpio)
-Drifting- By Trevor Crookston (BlazingDragon)
State of Flux (ft. Bracksta) By jxl180

Oh well..what can you do? :(


Art Requests (3)
Cliff Top Perch By EchoRun
Quarter Face Collab By Viridis
Pyscadellic Birds By David Neville (TheThinWhale)

All done.


Member's Update #5:
[#] [Total] [Total Stats] [Total Ratio] || [Gain] [Weekly Stats] [Weekly Ratio] [Username]

01 ) 571 | 88 / 88 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Coop83
02 ) 547 | 84 / 84 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Fro
03 ) 547 | 84 / 89 | 094.38% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Haggard
04 ) 498 | 79 / 88 | 089.77% || 090 | 15 / 22 | 068.18% SCTE3
05 ) 440 | 67 / 67 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% Insanimation
06 ) 400 | 62 / 89 | 069.66% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% MulticanimeFan

C'mon SCTE3, you're letting the side down! I see the Froggard contest it still raging on...

*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Fro, Haggard, Insanimation, MulticanimeFan and JKMonkey

Same as always..


GOTPENMUSTFLASH!

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 13:41:20


At 7/21/09 08:52 AM, Sonofkirk wrote:

thanks for the update sonofkirk! :D

Hey there, here is finally the update after two days of passionate waiting :P. The week was very contrasted between members that completed all the requests and those who were almost inactive - myself for instance -.-

well its about time you got the ball rolling, lol, jk, jk


I'm leaving on Wenesday for two weeks and I won't be able to update the list where I will be. I'll come back on Thursday 6th of August, so the list will be updated on Sunday 9th of August, that will make a lot of requests to complete for the update that will follow, so be ready.

have fun on your vacation man! :) just know youll be in for reviewing hell when you get back.

Also note that whoever make fun of my current whistle status will get kicked out of the list next update ;). Here are the requests you'll have to complete for the next update, on Sunday 9th of August, that is.

duly noted

Flash Requests (6)
Audio Requests (10)
Art Requests (3)

not so bad this week, only 19 reviews to get done


Member's Update #5:
07 ) 383 | 59 / 59 | 100.00% || 142 | 22 / 22 | 100.00% JKMonkey

^^ awesome, so I did do the audio and flash I had to do before the update, yes!


The stars indicate for how long the user has been inactive in this club. "Inactive" means, that user hasn't gained any points by reviewing OR by posting.
*: User has been inactive last week
**: User has been inactive for the last two weeks
***: User has been inactive for the last three weeks
****: User has been inactive for the last four weeks

^^ good idea

If you are inactive for more than three weeks AND if your completion rate falls below 20%, OR if you are inactive for more than four weeks you are excluded from the list. You may rejoin this club, but your points will be lost.

^^ duly noted


*All Requests Completed:
Coop83, Fro, Haggard, Insanimation, MulticanimeFan and JKMonkey

^^ excellent, good job guys, usual contenders on there


|"My dick was in the Guinness Boom of World Records... Then I left the library.|

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club 2009-07-21 14:10:43


Insanimation, JKmonkey and fro have been reveiwing basically everyones submissions! good job, I'm workin on a new art piece right now and I'll try to remember what you guys said.