This is an Official NGADM '18 Round 2 Review
Beginning Comments: Congratulations on making it to round 2
Production / Mixing: For what you have, this is nice. I think you could have brought the volume up a little bit, but again this is nice.
Composition / Structure: Oh man this is emotional. Nice solo piano, and has a very delicate feel. The progression is easy to digest, but man this is short. I don't know if it's been stated in the rules this year, but previous years past made a requirement of 2:30-3:00 minimum since that gives enough opportunity to develop an idea completely into a full song, which I would say this isn't. I can see in the description that you didn't have as much time, but I don't think I can fairly add a buffer to the score in that respect. Aside from that note (haha) the melody does a fair job in annunciating the intimacy of the theme. There wasn't anything as special about it, but that is the beauty of music. The notes themselves don't have to be technical or difficult to play, but not everyone could replay this song and get that same emotion out of if, so I give you props for that. It's actually bold I think to have something so simple this late in a NGADM contest.
Sound Design: Nice piano.
Ending Comments: I think it suffers from being a little short, but it doesn't lack in impact.
Production - 1.75
Composition - 1.75
Structure - 1.25
Sound Design - 2
Replay - 2
Total - 9.25
*Disclaimer - There is no disclaimer