I was listening to Johnfn's songs from ngadm 2013 because I randomly remembered some of his melodies and then I decided to listen to Steampianist's songs as well. Then I saw your reviews and decided to listen to your music. I know this is a very late review, but I want to get better at critiquing music.
The main melody is so catchy! Although the melodies are predictable, they still sound beautiful and cheerful. There isn't a single melody I dislike. I like the note change at 2:51; I did not expect that at all and it does a good job contrasting the most common chord. The tempo change transition is interesting; I never thought about doing that before and I will try it if I can remember. It sounds like the piano's reverb isn't constant throughout the song. I'm guessing you added reverb when the piano was alone. The mix doesn't sound good at 4:51, but this is my favorite part of the song because I love when piano and strings are played simultaneously. Besides for the mixing problems, which I know you didn't have enough time to fix, I only have one complaint: Although the piano itself sounds good, the positioning of its melodic notes sounds too perfect.
This is one of my new favorite songs!
Oh man, sorry for the late reply! I have become terrible at keeping up with reviews.
Thanks for the insightful review :). I'm fairly happy with most of the melodies here, even if they are rather simple, or even cheesy. Good catch on 2:51 - that's a a maj7 chord, which is basically a normal major chord but with the top note bumped down a semitone.
Piano verb should be constant, but it's definitely easier to hear when the piano is alone.
Aw I actually like 4:51's mix :(. A little muddy but I like the super warm and uplifting sound there.
Thanks a lot for dropping by!
Hey, I'm dedicating a level to you! (Geometry dash). It's name will be, "Independent". I never really made a good level and hope you like it!!! Love your music, it's calm exciting feeling that you can listen too anytime. P.S. check the level in 1-2 weeks. I'm probably not good enough to have it get stars, and it probably won't be rated.
Oh, good luck with your level! Thanks for leaving a review :).
Beautiful song. Great job
I'm glad you like it, despite the rush job it was! Thanks for reviewing :).
Hmm...this is different! I love the emotion and the climactic nature of it into 1:00. The intro might've been a little long, but it really has a simple beauty to it that compliments the film very well. I really love the victorious yet reflective mood. 1:55 was one of my favorite parts. Overall, it's well-structured, smooth-flowing, and has an appropriate amount of structural variation and dynamic contrast. It's at times upbeat and energetic, and at others slower and more emotional - just what I like in a piece of this style. May I ask why you chose to call it pop instead of classical or cinematic? Anyway, the quality of your instruments, as always, is superb. This could be a professional orchestra performing this right now, and I couldn't tell the difference. I also really liked the outro with the cellos and basses and then the soothing piano once again. Really good work, especially for making this in only one night, Step. :O Happy Independence Day, Malta! :D
Man, your reviews have become pretty much consistent. I always love reading what you have to say, so thanks a lot for yet another review!
The intro was on the long side, I'll agree, but my goal over there was simply to complement what was being shown on screen, as opposed to actually creating a musical progression that was a bit more sensible and didn't drag out as much, so I'm mostly glad I pulled that off haha.
Yeah I agree 1:52 is probably one of the stronger parts of the score, so I'm happy you like it!
Like I said to SilverFoxJams below me, I just felt like the instrumentation was more suited to pop, what with the piano, drums and guitar. It isn't really classical because it has almost no qualities of a classical piece of music. I guess maybe it could sorta fit in Cinematic, but ehhh. No biggie :3.
Once again, thanks a lot for reviewing! Gonna be posting two more tracks before the year ends.
I like how it gets from soothing, to exciting. Makes me smile. :)
The tricky part for me was to decide WHEN to change it to exciting, and how gradually to do so. Remember, this was a film score, and the scorer of the film basically dictates the excitement of the film, so it was important to make sure that the excitement levels were suitable.
Anyway glad you liked it :3.
Please contact me if you would like to use this in a project. We can discuss the details.