Eye-Cue V1 - Photo diss had potential, but homo followup? Too many doubles and sound effects, too fast and difficult to understand. What I did hear was pretty lame and generic.
Bummer V1 - Gay flip is good, Kathy Bates follow-up is hilarious. Art diss, age diss, lack of personal diss and a strong finisher.
Eye-Cue V2 - Art flip is okay, some horrible slant rhymes and filler.
Bummer V2 - Zero fucking personals is important, Picasso flip is weak, I could have written it better.
Bummer wins with more clarity, better delivery, more personals, and strong rhymes. I've seen Bummer go harder than this so points off for that.