Guitar Vs. Piano 1.2 rmk

Share Download this song

Author Comments

So, this is my remake of Guitar Vs. Piano (v1.2) by Goukisan - I finally got it to sound almost accurate to the original. but yeah, made it in all of about 4 hours of really dedicated work, so I hope you like it,

Log in / sign up to vote & review!

Newgrounds accounts are free and registered users see fewer ads!

i really liked is pretty awsome..... this renember some games

I liked it :) GodKnown can hate if he wants (though do appreciate the fact he took the time to write ALL THAT) and it is almost complacently accurate! if you listened to both the songs just one time over you probably wouldn't be able to tell too much of a diff.

Warn the ears of your listeners next time. Haha. That guitar is quite shrill, and annoyingly so, since I know it is just emulated. Maybe put a limiter on any frequencies above 15000, more or less. The drums are kind of dull and left unappreciated. The guitar just stays relatively the same all the way throughout the intro. Man, definitely need better drums, though. Start EQing your instruments a little more. The piano was alright. I wasn't impressed with it. I'm intrinsically unimpressed with the tune overall. It's just not much of a battle, in my opinion. They're more-so complementing each other in a way. Though, actually, toward the end, that's when I'm imagining more of a battle. I can see the dance going on, and that's pretty cool. So, overall, I'm not very satisfied listening through it, and I think it needs more work. Pay attention to the notes you're putting down, and pay attention to the production quality of your music. Remember, treat it like art, not just like some goal you're trying to get out of the way. Make this more of a journey!


lantaren responds:

I was trying to replicate goukisan's guitar Vs. Piano 1.2 as closely as possible, including the shrill guitar, and drum samples. I know it's not the best rendition ever, but I consider it to be a fairly good representation of how the song goes (being that every part is 1:1 with the original, including length) Yeah, I just honestly did not expect to be criticized so heavily on the composition part of this (being that I did 0 of that-it is 100% the original song, I changed nothing)

Credits & Info


Waiting for 1 more vote

Dec 16, 2012
4:21 PM EST
General Rock
File Info
9.8 MB
4 min 16 sec

Licensing Terms

You are free to copy, distribute and transmit this work under the following conditions:

You must give credit to the artist.
You may not use this work for commercial purposes. *

*Please contact me if you would like to use this in a commercial project. We can discuss the details.