Dangg that composition is spot on. Sure, there a buncha little errors here and there, which I'm sure you know all about by this point, but I thought you'd just like to know that the melodies are seriously great.

You know what this reminds me of? Wind Waker. Particularly the sailing theme - it has that same sort of boundless optimism to it, which is something that I really enjoy in music.

You're actually one of my bigger influences on Newgrounds, because your specific brand of melodicism and your approach to music in general just really speaks to me. I hope to hear much more music from you. :)

This is not bad at all. The melodies feel very familiar, though... It's not that they are identical to something that was already done, but they do leave an impression of being a little generic.

Interesting piece.

I'm impressed with this piece. Thoughtful approach; I like that the melody falls to the lower strings and is countered by the high winds, followed by low brass, etc. - makes for an interesting listening experience. Well done.

This submission definitely has one of the best and most unusual themes. The harmonic content of this track is just amazing, and in my opinion the most immediately impressive part. After a long while of struggling with the guitar to find out just what the hell you're doing with the chords, I just can't figure it out. It's kind of lydian, kind of harmonic minor, kind of none of these and kind of both, all I know for sure is it's intriguing as hell.

The instrumentation fits the composition perfectly. Particularly the opening stands out to me as incredibly lifelike, but the instruments sound great and organic throughout the rest too (that double bass has balls, man). The piece also has moments like 1:06 where the sophistication gives way to beauty for a moment. And everything just flows nicely and smoothly.

I have two problems with this song, a major one and a minor one: It simply doesn't have the length to really develop enough to amaze me, and the trumpets sound somewhat off. :)

9.3/10