Oh good work
Some of these melodies are awesome, some a bit creepy and remind me of clowns. lol. Anyway yeah cool job :D I purticuly like the 80s style soundtrack style ones (Even if you weren't going for that, that's what it gives off to me)
I'm *never* going for that but i usually end up with it anyway :P
Heh, you wanted a long review?
Yeah, you guessed it. I'm not the kind of one-line reviewer, so I'm going to comment on each and every one of the interesting ones. (Let's hope the character limit helps me out here...)
'Idea 184': Those pan flutes sound really amazing. Nothing to complain about here. It sounds difficult to make a song out of, but sound great as it is :D.
'Bunnyinspired': One really catchy melody, and the guitarish melody you use in the background harmonized perfectly. You could definitely make a song out of this one, if you get the inspiration.
'Your Journey': Now this one is my favourite. It sound so well done, and even though it's only a small melody, I can imagine this as an amazing song. Some strings could help over here.
'footstepsofbunnies': I didn't hear the original, but this sounds quite familiar. Doesn't sound anything like footstepsofbunnies O_o.
'elmtail_idea2': Not too bad. The choirs sound excellent, but I suggest some male choirs in the background to give a mighty feel to the song.
'Elmtail': Not one of the catchier melodies you made, but it sounds OK. Strings, like in 'Your Journey', could work out here too.
'pokemon_trailer': A little quiet, and I was looking for more of a buildup with the instrument that was playing the main melody, maybe getting a bit louder, and have some drums in the background too. That is, if by some miracle you want to continue it :P.
'HP_TheArena': The piano flows vey nicely in this song. You could add something a little more impressive than just a kick every 2 beats.
'Mountain_Flowers_rmx': Wow, this sounds really good. If you're planning on making a mellow mix of Mountain Flowers (which would be awesome. The original has too many loud saw synths >[ ) this is a great start. The notes after don't sound exactly like the original, but maybe that was intentional.
'idea286': This is quite short, but it sounds like a really good transition to use in a future song. Needs a bit more fullness to it, IMO.
'ryanide_wingsofbluefire': I didn't hear the original, so I can't compare this to that, and probably if I google it, the only preview will be on youtube, which doesn't work on my hunk of junk; sorry, computer. Anyway, this needs a bit more fullness in it, but overall it sounds ok. I'd suggest some heavy piano chords in the background.
'twoheroesvillage': Can't critique this. You already made it into a song, and it rocks.
'UniversalRisermx': I didn't hear the original of this either, but the remix you did sounds cool. Nothing to complain over there ^^.
'redwallthemething': Sounds really good. Needs some more instruments in it, but the flute melody sounds very well done. Good job.
'redwalltheme2': Hey, this sounds quite good when paired with the one before it. Maybe you could try and combine them into a song?
'idea 138': Slightly strange, and I don't really think you can make a song out of it, but if you do, I suggest more synths in the background.
'idea 164': A little too slow and dull, but doesn't sound too bad. A fast drum beat might make it have a seemingly faster rythm, if you don't want to increase the tempo.
'idea 169': Definitely needs more fullness to it, if you're aiming for ambient. It sounds fine, but needs a synth in the background which sounds good when playing long notes.
'idea173': Sounds really awesome. I don't blame you about not being able to turn it into a song, I can't seem to think of a way either.
'idea204': I don't think you stole it. Sounds original to me. Plus, it doesn't sound too bad.
'idea239': A more climatic melody with loud drums and some choir voices and you have a perfect battle melody ^^.
'idea251': You scrapped the song? :(. I'm sure it would've sounded fine. I like the melody you used over here.
'idea269': 324 unnamed ideas? Wow... This one sounds pretty awesome, especially in a menu theme for a game or something.
Phew, just made it through the character limit. Nice job on it overall.
-Review Request Club-
And the limit ends right... over... here......
You suck :C
'bunnyinspired' Yeah, but i lost it
'stupidbunniesthing' Its the most ridiculously generic trance melody ever.
'Mountain_Flowers_rmx' - The change in notes is deliberate, yes, but I had no idea what to do for the rest of the song. The intro works, but then it just dies.
'idea286' - its an IDEA for gods sake
'redwalltheme2' - I doubt combining them, but they are related.
'idea251' - I got sick of it. It was trying too hard to sound cool
'idea269' - technically its about 302 since many of them ended up getting finished and given names
So shouldn't we put this here as like, the longest song description ever and the longest review ever? :P
There's just one problem though, an that is that the timings for the sequences seem off. but good work so 10/10. oh and can I have the flp?
You have to specify which idea you want, since they're 94 different FLP files.
And again -
Great title name xD
It's those names that bring my eyes to this.
Beautiful choices btw, ;)
lol thanks XD
Great lineup dude, i normally dont like these kinda things but this is great, well done.
Please contact me if you would like to use this in a project. We can discuss the details.