Beat me to it
I was just about to finish my G/S/C version... wow
Melody: 1/2- Good, but I think the melody should be a calmer instrument. I really did not like the one from D/P/Pt, it seemed off.
Bass: 2/2- Sufficient
Drums: N/A- As my grade system goes, if there is no bass or drums, the instruments used section becomes out of 4 instead of two.
Instruments: 2/4- Not bad, just not great. The main melody could have been a bit more mellow, because its a surfing melody.
Mood: 1/2- Half and half. At some times, it was great, at some times it wasnt.
OVERALL: 6/10- not bad