This took me on a deep and emotional journey. Thank you :)
You are absolutely welcome.
That's not sequenced....
A live piano recording on newgrounds ?! You need to remove this right now. Real talent on NG ? !?!??! ABSOLUTELY UN CALLED FOR! !!
Srsly .. I wish I could say I was kidding when I tell you that I just counted 2 tears rolling down my cheek.
Even with the emotional context of the story put aside. This is an absolutely beautiful song. And it's live .. it's real.. it's not a computer playing some sequenced notes.
Thank you for this. Thank you so much.
Can't believe I didn't read this before.
Thanks so much for your response. You're legit my favorite artist on Newgrounds, so to read your serious comment is...like...A U2 fan being kissed by Bono. Except less creepy.
The last couple versions were getting a bit of disapproval for not having a higher quality mic, or being more properly mastered. I replied politely that A) I did not have those resources B) If I did, I might not use them. The emotion behind the song is raw, and thus the song itself will be raw.
Hymns in general just invite medley. Thanks for being a part of mine.
Wow =D Really great, you recorded a new one ^^
Thanks. This belongs to my playlist :D:D:D
You really are a virtuoso, changing tempo and style in just one song like this, I like that <3
I really love the composition for this piece! as nintesu said, I think that the 0:46-0:55 doesn't fit in with the overall emotion of the song, however, I do like the new part you have added 1:23-End even though the end of the original was nice. I downloaded Version 3 before you removed it, and I think that is my favourite version of Heart Of Melodies even with that error in, because of the echoing you could hear when it was playing. However, for this recording, it was beyond your control so I shouldn't question it.
Overall, I think this is a fantastic composition you have made and it is filled with emotion. If you are to try this again, I would definitely remove the 0:46-0:55 and just keep it how you had it in Version 3, and if somehow you can get that reverb back, that would be excellent. Nonetheless, this is great, very calming and it helps me think clearly, really happy I stumbled across this masterpiece!
Its been awhile
In my opinion this version is not as great as your origional. Now do not get me wrong my friend this is still a great track worth mentioning, though I feel as though the emotion you put in your first version is not as well in touch with this one. This one is only 9 seconds longer but it seems as though those 9 seconds were not needed since your origional was amazing and did not need any tampering. from 00:46-00:55 thats where your 9secs was added and that is where ppl say there is humor. IT DOES NOT FIT and takes away from the emotional feeling we all loved and adored in the origional and makes it sound more active and fun instead of heart touching and emotional.
In my opinion get rid of that. Leave the origional the way it was. I still have it on my ipod. I only gave it a 9 instead of a 10 because the 9sec part.
Please do not take any of this the wrong way, I had submitted a review on your previous version if you do not remember me.
Please contact me if you would like to use this in a project. We can discuss the details.