I've been playing guitar for 18 years and have listened and enjoyed all genres of music, from classical to death metal, rap to native american. I just don't understand how you can suppose someone is going to like your song for its guitar work. I'm not saying it's pure crap, but I don't find it all that catchy or extraordinary or original . Plus, the drums are too loud for a song you're boasting guitar for.
Now, don't take this as a negative rebuttal because you rated a song of mine as "pretty stanky". I'm mature enough to be able to take criticism and not lash out against it. But since you said in your review of my song that it would be good if it was your style of music, I figured your style must be superb enough to deny all others as something less than. I honestly think you should tuck your ego back in your pocket and walk on.
I appreciated your honesty; although, it wasn't very descriptive. So please accept mine.
ok...ok. I guess i can agree with some of what you said. it wasnt really right for me to bag on your song for not liking the style. that doesnt make it a bad song. the drums are a little loud but the reason for that is that this is a demo song and was recorded with a single mic above our jam. so if i had the option to adjust all of the levels seperately than i would have considered some changes. But i do think that i have the right to make the statement "if you like guitar than i think that you would like this song" becuase it is revolved comepletly around my friend and my guitar work together. It could be interesting to a guitar player that its instrumental and all guitar. But also, thanks for your honest review. sorry i didnt take my review of your song more seriously. :)