all in all,
Karkat doesn't have a penis, so Dave Stryder wins. Inter special relationships just don't work out, trust me. About the picture itself, I love the style, it is a tough style to pull off ( or at least I think so). The way Karkat is holding the sickle is odd, his thumb should be wrapped around it more and the angle of his hand (or the sickle) needs to be fixed. I love homestuck but that won't affect my score. I think I would give more of a 6.5 out of 10. That is good, Getting a 10 from me is nearly impossible. One last thing, Karkat's horns could be a bit bigger and more colorful, they look like elf ears. :D