Tbh that water is probably fine it just looks weird because if you are used to seeing the screen come up the water is panning, trying to make how that looks as a still image can be kinda weird probably. Nice recreation, the super classic sonic with that little bit of charm of 80s aesthetic hold over with stuff like the bold metallic text is always a favorite zone for me aesthetically.

The water needs some work, but everything else is great!

Nice man :D