Well, I guess I'm glad I reviewed this at least sort of around Halloween. While not a fan of the show, I think this is really good. You really do capture the likeness of the characters. This doesn't seem to be like a Treehouse of Horror episode. Everything seems mundane. It kind of makes you wonder what it would be like if they had a mundane Halloween episode.
Of course, they have supernatural stuff in the regular show all the time now. Okay, enough show analysis. I think my favorite is probably Homer. His essence is really captured with the red jelly doughnut. Bart's is great too.