Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

I wish I could give more than three stars.

I like the style, it's cute. Backstory is nice, short enough. (Sometimes longer stories are so unnecessary, at least in my opinion and in terms of Flash games ...)
Very graphic game. Puzzles are somewhat "easy", but there's a problem: The controls! I've learned to try many possible combinations, trial and error, no problem for me in that. But if the game doesn't react, it's frustrating! I did look at the walkthrough and I say I did try the things I had missed, at least for the most part!
I find it boring to use walkthroughs, thanks for providing it though.

Overall it's a nice game, the puzzles are in some sense easy (just click and click), but the reaction area is so small and selection of the actions feels ackward.

And thanks for the medals!

I HATE SLIDER PUZZLES.

Now that that's outta the way. Game was okay. Wish that there was descriptions of the items you pick up (still don't know what that stick thing was, and I thought the sheet was a treasure map). Wasn't fond of the whole "give these random items to random dudes" aspect. I like puzzle solving, not guessing. Also, what's the ending about? I guess she got a pet dragon and... found a... portal? A story ender would be nice!

On the good side, graphics were nice, the puzzles that didn't involve gift-giving were good, and the beginning story line was cute! I didn't have any issues with lag.

I feel that just a little bit more tweaking would make this game awesome!

puzzle's a bit difficult and none of the medals worked for me

Great graphics, great music and solid puzzles! Only three stars because it just didn't quite feel like it all came together to me...

Could be improved a lot by: i) tweaking the experience to cut out unnecessary delays (e.g. the giant axe and shield between every screen was really unnecessary; the girl takes a long time to shrug, which is annoying when you want to try a bunch of items out somewhere; and you could cut out some of the unnecessary 'puzzles', like having to place the compass on the table - a few things like this just seemed to me to be creating needless obstacles); and ii) adding some kind of story / dialogue to give me motivation to move through the game. I know there's the cut scene at the start, but it didn't give me much to go by, and for most of the game I felt like I was wondering around trying to get things to interact with each other, but not really having a sense of why on earth I was doing any of it. e.g. even just setting up at the start three main goals - need to get a ship; some bait; and a net... would have helped a lot.

Very nice piece of work though - like I said at first, all the core stuff (graphics, musics, puzzles) are really well done.

the "hm-hmm" part the girl does really slows down the time for me