Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Potential Classic, but has some issues

First, with the good.
The art is beautiful. The portraits are clean. The town music works well, and doesn't seem to grate on me, even if I'm listening to it repeatedly. So far, I believe the research and upgrades are balanced, although I found fair trading to be useless. (only seems to affect the resource for gold transactions). All buttons work correctly and the game is easy to pick up.

The battles are similar of other flash warfare games. Each fighter sticks to a lane. This means that I find only the gunners and the horse archers tend to be the type I use in these types of games-especially considering that any melee soldiers you send out tend to get heavily damaged before they can do any damage in return.

I do have a few suggestions for features to add, though. Buildings like the marketplace, the blacksmith and the weapon seller are probably the most important structures in the game, but it's a hassle to click on the minimap, click again on the appropriate box, and then click once more on the building to enter the screen. You could have made some hotkeys to instantly transport between each of them (once the appropriate structure is built, of course)

Also, with said structures, you should probably have made a slider bar or probably a number input dialog for buying and selling goods. It's very annoying to click an icon repeatedly (upwards to hundreds of times in the mid-late game).

You could have placed a projected resource income for next turn somewhere with the resource icons at the top.

In battle, you could have made hotkeys to assign your troops. For example, the player could press 1 to activate the swordsman icon, and then click a row,

I'm not totally clear on what traps do either. I never needed them, though.

The economy in this game is kinda funny. I've been able to buy materials frequently (literally in the thousands), at the same price. Must be some pretty dumb merchants. There is no sense of higher demand, higher price and vice versa.

My main gold income for the first couple days was creating bows (or guns if I have less wood) and then selling them at the weapon seller. Of course, the question then comes up-who exactly am I selling it to, since we're supposed to be the last village? I can't possibly be selling the weapons to some other tribe, let alone, the white invaders. And I can't be selling it to my own tribe either.

Because of the static market prices, though, players can easily create weapons for cheap and then sell them at huge profits. Then the player can proceed to buy more materials than they started with (until the lady says you can't anymore), create bows or guns, and then sell again. (I could reserve some bows to train gunners and bowmen, as they are the most effective fighting units)

It was only around day 30, and I already had all the weapon upgrades, with all wood and iron production buildings at least at level 6-7. In a battle around that time, I sent out swarms of gunners and archers, (no potion required) massacred the attackers (shouldn't have been the other way around?) and then stole 8000 gold (pick pocket not researched yet) because of all the guys who broke through enemy lines.

I don't know if that's what you guys intended, but it made the game much easier for me.

Sure, it isn't factually or economically accurate. Sure, it might have game breaking flaws and moments where I felt I was going to get either carpal tunnel syndrome or a broken mouse button from clicking buttons too many times. But I definitely had fun finding the best way for the tribe to survive, treating this more as a what-if scenario more than a game based on real history.

awesome game

really nice game reminded me of age of war
ther were some minor glitches such as sometimes the super hero power wouldn't work but other than that great job

Really good stuff

Great too see a game with some Indians kicking some butt.

This is very amazing.

You need to send it to some sort of video game company, it's amazing! At least by Newgrounds standards, it is.

A couple of points regarding balance...

This game is really great, don't get me wrong. However I think it needs balancing, unless such were your intentions.

Early on, the commanders themselves can hold off any invading army (almost). There is no incentive to send troops out there to die. Yes, if they get to the other side you'll be rewarded with gold, but they cost a lot to train and upgrade in the first place.

You can spend the early part simply building up your economy and upgrading all the production buildings, then start upgrading the weapons and towers and massing troops. Whatever gold you're missing out from not sending troops in battle, you're gaining it from resources (more than you'll ever need to spend anyway)

However, I never needed to use troops. The magic potions are ridiculous. Even till the very end, 3 ranged commanders with magic potion simply stop EVERYTHING. Sending troops becomes a hassle. There ought to be a more streamlined way of sending them out, possibly incorporating hotkeys or queues. Clicking one by one is annoying, no surprise I just stuck with my commanders. Well, actually I just wanted to see when the commanders-only tactic could last me, so I was really quite surprised when I survived till day 75 using just that. Well I suppose that was only possible cuz I saved up all the potions from early on...