Score: 5

"Collab?"

by: Ericho

date: December 4, 2009

Gee, it's so hard for me to rank this low, as it was intended to be for a collab. I mean, it jut doesn't seem like much, with the simple animation of the whale falling. I think the song is pretty good, but it can get annoying after awhile with just the same song. It's too bad this didn't go in that collab as I'm sure it would too much better accomodated by other things. Still, you at least tried to make this good for something even if it did not succeed. I hope you are able to get into collabs where this can be appreciated much more.

Score: 8

"haha"

by: sammy123lol

date: November 9, 2008

I think his unusual smile is the best hes like "yay...fallling...yay..uh..noo"
*sad face* then if you'd have finished it his smile would be a frown and he'd be like "god dammit"

Score: 7

"Would of been great."

by: Fro

date: June 27, 2008

Animation / Graphics - Great animation and great drawing. Pretty good all around. It might of been just a bit glitchy when the whale was flipping, but not to noticeable though.

Story - I'm sure this would of been a great addition to the Music Video Collab. Too bad you didn't make it in time though. Oh well, it seemed to pass all by itself. There was a bit of humor in it too, so that helped your score a little. I mean it's not everyday you see a whale falling through the sky.

Audio - This song couldn't of went any better with the animation. Good job.

Overall, it's nothing too great by itself, but it would of been a great addition to the collab.

C52

Score: 8

"Haha, nice."

by: TheNossinator

date: June 27, 2008

Nice animation and song choice for this one, it would be nice if it were a little longer, but I realise that this was originally for a collab so you probably can't chance that.

Nice work, keep it up.

Score: 8

"Funny concept"

by: watzerenaufe

date: June 26, 2008

it was fun and a random concept,i wished it was abit longer and to see him land, then i would have give it a 10 :)