Score: 10

"beautiful"

by: ManiacZaniac

date: March 1, 2008

some parts were just beautiful
but i dont quite get it but it was awesome
good job man

Score: 6

"Beatles..."

by: amodelqueso

date: February 23, 2008

The Beatles are good and I respect their music. I'm sorry for your loss, but I've seen too many fakers on NG to give any pity to anyone. If he really did die than I'm sorry, but this animation had some good qualities, but was basically just a mashup of some different parts. Your graphic quality was inconsistent and didn't appeal to the eye at all. I feel there may be many giving this a high score from pity, and I need to let those people know that the voting system is for animation, not "Author's Comments". Seriously, take away your comments and you may notice a difference. And to all of those who think I am being a hard-ass well tough. I know you may be feeling pain but NG isn't the place you want to look for sympathetic people. The way you put "Enjoy!" right there sorta defeats a lot of the sadness you gather up. But aside that, you do have some good animation points in there, though the graphic quality, if raised, would increase the overall quality of this animation.

Score: 10

"Excellent"

by: superstatguy

date: February 22, 2008

It's sad to hear of your loss; it's always hard to lose someone who is a close friend.
My aunt was named Michelle after the tune on Rubber Soul, so my family and I obviously grew up listening to the Beatles all the time; I listen to Abbey Road as I write this review.
Dear Prudence is one of the finest ballads John ever wrote, so it was a fitting song to use here; it's a beautiful song, and I am sure your friend would have appreciated you using it.
I hope you can recover from the tragedy, and I wish you good luck in the future.
- Superstatguy.