Be a Supporter!

Credits & Info

Uploaded
Apr 9, 2007 | 6:05 PM EDT

If you liked this, check these out!


Plenty more like this here!


  • Salad Fingers
    Salad Fingers A strange cartoon about a creature who loves to touch rusty metal.

Author Comments

uugghhh

Reviews


PenniPigtailsPenniPigtails

Rated 1.5 / 5 stars

Meh

It made it a bit creepier and took away the strange sense of innocence that is quintessentially Salad Fingers. It's a bit like when Stephen Spieldberg started screwing with his classic films to make them "better". That's all I could think of the whole time I watched this.

It takes a truly skilled hand to improve upon a classic, and not many can achieve it. I like Salad Fingers for it's simplicity and subtlety. This remake kind of bashes you over the head with the "creepy" aspect of Salad Fingers and forgets to acknowledge the side of Mr Fingers that is somewhat naive and oblivious to the terrible world around him.

The animation is also quite jerky, I think it might be a bit better if you smoothed it out, and lay off the cuts to scribbles.


People find this review helpful!

Renegade-HamsterRenegade-Hamster

Rated 1.5 / 5 stars

You could go further with this

The graphics are better, but not by much. If you truly wanted to make this your own cartoon and not just a very similar version of the original, you should have made the graphics completely different and amazing.

I also think you should have kept the hand-drawn wriggling letter forms that David uses in the Salad Fingers series instead of just copping out with computer generated type.

1/5 (almost a 2)

The low score is because it's basically David Firth's material, and you've got to make something much more amazing than this to call it your own.


Oney responds:

I wasn't trying to make this my own cartoon. Read the Commentry, all I wanted to do was change the graphics. Doiy


thundermarhthundermarh

Rated 1.5 / 5 stars

rip off

I liked it... but you used little or no imagination in making it. I mean... I think anything that is a take off trying to be as good as the original is a peice of crap.



jbbigjbbig

Rated 1.5 / 5 stars

It was okay!

It was good but I do not like that weirdo salad fingers what is he any way!



giobot123456789giobot123456789

Rated 1.5 / 5 stars

that was creepy