Score: 6

"Nice."

by: Protosscat123

date: June 9, 2009

I know it's an old project of yours, but I can't say it was as good as the Starcraft series.

First of all, the aircraft models were a bit off. The MiG-21 was great overall, but a bit too short. The F-18 Hornets had only one engine with two flames coming out of it, and the fuselage was too fat. In combat, the F-18's could kick any MiG's ass any day of the week nowadays, so that wasn't entirely a fair fight. And you can't lock on to other missiles anyway. To evade, a plane would have to deploy chaff or flares (depending on the missile type) which would fool the missile into thinking it is still tracking the aircraft. And if you were attempting to take down an enemy aircraft via SAM's, launching 3 missiles would be a waste. Also, the F-18's machine gun would sound more of a hum than a click, and would literally blow apart any MiG-21 with a single shot, due to the cannon's high calibre rounds.

Despite this, it was a good movie. The action is great, and I like you you included the enemy HUD as well. And the black and white tone adds emphasis. While it's unlikely any F-18 will engage a MiG-21 soon, it shows how a little strategy goes a long way, especially with a great durable aircraft like the F-18.

Score: 8

"sigh."

by: WorldWalker128

date: May 8, 2009

I like the video with no complaints save one: Profanity.

I know that the military uses it more often than most people, but even so.
-

other than that, very good work. Liked the music, liked the voice-acting, and the vast majority of the animation work. Even without color it was easy to tell one object from another even when it came to telling the 'good guys' from the 'bad guys'.

Score: 10

"Fuckin Awesoome."

by: Prometheus5

date: August 8, 2008

I loved it. You should for sure make more I love this kind of stuff anyway fucking amazing.

Score: 9

"Star craft was better"

by: kidmerc

date: July 6, 2008

i thought the Star craft story was better also it was more funnier and kewler and stuff you know that feeling like you connect to it if you ever played Starcraft

Score: 8

"could be more polished, but then im just nitpickin"

by: daryl2158

date: May 26, 2008

it was a great animation, lots of effort put into it. but the later action sequences actually looked more polished than the beginning, strangely. Usually people would make the models in the action sequences simpler. The initial models when the planes were about to take off looked a bit rough, and the wheels were abit weird too.

coming from a guy who's played too many air combat simulators for his own good, i'd say a tip is to study actual dogfight tactics and incorporate them into your movie if ur doing a dogfighting scene. currently its a little off, like how that guy managed to evade radar, and needing a visual, and how u can fire a missile to hit another missile.

other than that, great job as always, logfish!