Score: 8
"I like it, but it could be better..."
date: July 27, 2005
Overall, I like this a lot. It's a touching song and the video matches it very well. I can kinda see why someone would describe it as 'too literal', but sometimes it's nice to see something literal. I liked the graphics and effects, though I found that the art itself could use a little improvement at times. My biggest problem was I found the physical heart (especially the one with the screw and the blood) a gratuitous and it really messed up the flow of the video for me. My favorite thing was the shots where the girl has a determined look on her face. It was kinda nice that rather then be all sobby and blubbery, she actually had the courage to defy him and then grieve alone... I don't know, that's probably very weird to hear, but it makes sense to me. Anyways, overall I liked it a lot, but I'm a critiquer by nature, please don't take offense.