Be a Supporter!

NGs' Guide to Reviewing!

Score:
rated 2.53 / 5 stars
Views:
3,882 Views
Share Links:
Genre:
More Movies
Tags:
None

Credits & Info

Uploaded
Mar 18, 2005 | 4:08 AM EST

Author Comments

Project GUISE(Graphic User Interface Special Edition) is complete and this is the first guide to use it. You should see a large rise in quality and efficiency.

This time it's all about reviewing. How to become a respected reviewer, how NOT to get banned and how to tell an author EXACTLY what you thought of his movie.
Enjoy
-Potski
P.S. Apologies for the large filesize, something must have gone wrong while optimizing.

Reviews


GroundChuckClockGroundChuckClock

Rated 4.5 / 5 stars

Coolio!

I really liked it, but it could have ben a tad longer, you know?


People find this review helpful!
Potski responds:

Thanks for the review. I guess it could have been longer, and will work on it next time :)


rovrov

Rated 0 / 5 stars

that sucked

and i can just read the faq this is stupid.


Potski responds:

Congratulations, you are smarter than the average NGer. Now move along...


thecrimsonsidewalkthecrimsonsidewalk

Rated 2 / 5 stars

thanks for the NG's guide to reviewing

can you also make a guide for blowing the wistle?


Potski responds:

That's a little too simple, even for this series.


MausMaus

Rated 2 / 5 stars

...

Light text on a busy background makes it very hard to read. Your 'buttons' were poorly executed. Try making a box around the words, instead of making the user hover the mouse directly on a letter.

I know better than to wear headphones whilst watching random flashes, so I can't comment on the sound.

As for the actual content. All of it was common sense. All of it is covered in the review guidelines. Perhaps a more indepth piece with actual graphics demonstrating what you're talking about, like flagging abusive reviews.



hack314hack314

Rated 1 / 5 stars

pointless

I don't understand why you put this on here.. I don't want to be told HOW to review something that sucks.. It would help if yours didn't suck too.. like try learning how to make buttons right. Hmm.. what do I flag this crap now?..


Potski responds:

Bad review, I recommend you read the guide again.