Tired of waiting?
Click here to disable ads!
You are not logged in. If you sign up for an account,
you can gain additional voting power over time, allowing your vote to have an even
greater impact on submission scores!
It's the fifth one in what now seems to be a "Quintilogy"..?
? I think you've waited long enough.
Dave - www.fat-pie.com
Pointless. Has style, but it's wasted.
Well, I don't know what all of you guys are on, but simply put, this animation was simply pointless.
I'll break it down a little bit more:
Animation: Aside from lipsyncing, the animation was pretty poor. Everything only moves in 2 dimensions with no depth. Example: The girls' legs are facing right, when her body's facing forward, as she moves right. Also, it wouldn't kill to have the art be higher quality. Given the time the artist obviously puts in to these, he should spend some time working on his artistic skills. Colour theory and general skills can really help in conveying the right atmosphere.
Sound: It was good, and basically what made the atmosphere engaging. Obvious influence from Aphex Twins. The voice of Mr. Fingers just gets annoying though. There's a line between annoying and disturbing, and mr. Fingers dances heartily on the annoying side.
Style: The atmosphere is pretty good. If you put in an actual plot, or ideas, instead of just random stuff, you could come up with something actually good.
Overall: Despite the weak graphics, what really kills the animation is that there is NO point. The thing goes WAY too slow, and there is no payoff. Although good contrast to the other noises, it's simply too much. There is no plot to speak of, there are no funny bits, there is no entertainment value. Unlike the others eps, he doesn't do anything thats painfully disturbing (such as put a finger through a meat hook), so you don't even get those feelings of unease like the others. I think the artist should first sit down and plan a plot, idea, or theme to do before creating another mr. Fingers. For examples, look at and disect an Aphex Twin video. What makes it work, despite the seeming randomness of it all.
Wanna know what I got from the thing? You're making fun of mentally ill people. Without any attempt to make it funny.
Where's the plot..
It would have been good, if it did'nt seem like you were trying to make it weird.If it had some plot besides a picnic and a bunch of random shit that followed, it would have been better.It was original, but that is'nt everything sometimes.Take out the 5 minutes of random bullshit, and add a plot in its place...
Salad fingers haters unite!
Wow.Not scary,not funny,what the hell is all you people's problems?This SUCKS.Maybe if I was like,fucken burntout,I would like this.But,i'm not a filthy scab,and I appreciate GOOD artwork.The 7 for style was because...it has style.Look at it!it's fucked up.Straight fucked up.I gave Humor 2,because the part where he was talking into the broken phone...that was actually funny.Otherwise,this is crap.
whoever makes these cartoons...wow im just lost of words...go back and play your...videogames there uhhhh David firth ya that david firth, dont make any more of these cartoons cause uhhh...not very good.
thisshit gets weirder but it has gotten better i must admit
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.