Score: 6

"Special review there..."

by: MangaGirl

date: March 19, 2007

This one is hard for me to review since there so many of you...

Crazylegs07: I think your best part was your lil man doing martial arts together. The animation was fluid (we could feel the movements well!) Good job there. Also I really liked the house you draw :) .

CrazyPanda: I like your cartoon style, but I was impressed by that very little scene without color. I would be curious to see a work from you all in that style -black and white. (full motion animated of course)

Smlf and Starogre: You are great at animating stick figures! I liked the full motion of it, the fluidity, and the funny things they does.

Even tough the quality of your work could be greatly improved in it's totallity, I was amazed to see so much good animation in it. All I can say is you guys got a lot of potential! I really will be looking for some more of your works. If you guys gets really into it, you may be able to become real animators someday (why do follow some classes at college or something!). At least it is what I believe for now. Keep up the good work!

Score: 4

"You guys seriously need work."

by: MeepClock

date: February 22, 2007

Okay, I played this thinking hey, "I like greenday, and this is a pretty good song by them."
However, when the menu came up, i was dissapointed in the graphics, the almost blinding brightness of the menu and the flash pieces them selves.
On the Audio portion;
If you wanted to shorten the song, you shouldve spliced it at a part where it wouldnt be completely obvouis, or animated more to fill up the song. I think the menu was the worst part with thtat indian-sounding rythym, that doesnt fit at all.
The graphics; There were maybe two artists i could bear to watch for their whole part. You guy sSERIOUSLY need practice on drawing people and actions, Make some of your drawings maybe relevant to the song, because, seriously, i was dissapointed, and why was there a neon tree on the menu and a random squiggle in the background?
Humor;
It was funny. at all. which i dont think it was supposed to be or should be.
Interactivity;
nothing special
Style:
nothing to say here. it was all the same.

Score: 4

"here's a tip"

by: MetallicaMan89

date: December 15, 2006

next time if your gonna make another collab, try to make it relevant to the song and not random bullshit like what i saw

and also.........PLAY THE WHOLE DAMN SONG!!!!!!!!

Score: 1

"Sucks"

by: guywholiveshere

date: October 29, 2006

the animation wasn't good, and it didn't follow the song. it's about growing up in oakland, california. why draw some island when the song clearly calls "paradise" a slum.

Score: 10

"Green Day rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

by: hardcore1023

date: July 6, 2006

This is the best collab i've ever seen keep it up.