Score: 5
"Where to start?"
date: September 2, 2005
I love this song, and I may be being a little bit harsh because I didn't feel the animation did it justice, although there is obviously a lot of emotion behind it. The movie got better as it went along in a few aspects... it started to make a little more sense, and the video started merging with the ups and downs in the music (although that should have been done throughout the movie). One of the main problems I had with this movie was that it kept using the same scenes OVER AND OVER. I understand that it's a long song, and you might want to reuse some things, but that was ridiculous. There was also very little animation... only zooms and fades, and a few minor things. This was essentially a slideshow, which may have been what you were aiming for, so thats ok... it just started to get a little boring between that and the repetitiveness of the scenes. And, this may be a little picky of me, but the "I Hate You"'s were over the top. I just don't think the singer does. But, like I said, thats just my opinion, and I don't hold that against you. Very good art though. Also, Konstantine is only blonde in one scene...
Author's Response:
Thanks for the review! :) its very cool to get good long reviwes. I agree with you on a lot of points... and yes its basicly a slide show, there are reasions behind that, that i'm still devloping for other work (but thats a whole diffrent story and would take to long to get in to) the "i htae you"'s were over the top, which was kind of hte point :) the reuses of scene was kind of a sticking point for me, i always wanted to do more, but you just get to a point where you are just sick of somthing and messing with it any more can only do more harm than good. but ya... thanks again :)