Pretty good!

Well, it was alot better than I expected! Alot of first timers are pretty bad but yours is suprisingly good. The graphics were good, but it was a lil too quiet. Also, it seemed incomplete, due to the lack of "strategic scene transition".
Meaning, you need to work on the presentation. Very good for a first. Remember, the more you make, the more you learn, the better you get!!!

Decent for your first movie....

The graphics were decent for being your first animation but there wasn't any sound and the plot was extremely boring.

Okay not bad...

I liked your animation, but the plot is very boring. You could atleast make it longer.

Not very good.

I was interested in this just because my name is Josh and my father's name is Richard. I didn't enjoy watching this movie at all. <_<

ehh, average

eck.. Boring you need more practice and a better story line. Voices would be nice too.