Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Score: 9

"You have returned!"

by: I-wont-tell

date: November 20, 2007

Yay!!! This flash was great man, another classic. I loved Tom bombadil's voice, it was the best part of the flash and every once and a while I laughed at his voice while he was narrating. Great job!

Score: 10

"Win, as usual."

by: macfluffers

date: November 20, 2007

Not much to be said, really. Just like always, your stuff is just plain incredible.

Score: 10

""hehe!""

by: Vampirekitty3

date: November 20, 2007

I loved all your past ones, Hobbits or not. I love this one too. Please keep up the awesome work!

Score: 10

"This was Awesome"

by: SimCorder

date: November 20, 2007

I'm a fan of the hobbit, and seeing a movie like this just made my day.

Graphics 10/10 (Most of your movies are really well drawn and animated)
Audio 10/10 (Good voice acting and use of music)
Humor 8.5/10 (Although some of your jokes weren't funny they were fun to watch)

Excellent work,

Score: 9

"heh heh"

by: toxicdevil93

date: November 20, 2007

Funny only thing you must improve on are graphics

Score: 10

"Can't wait for part two"

by: Razmere

date: November 20, 2007

This was a perfect parody/re telling of the classic hobbit story. Can we expect part two anytime soon?

Score: 9

"sweet but wierd"

by: Hunter747

date: November 20, 2007

dam thats good, king of creepy but good, i cant wait till the next one comes out!

Score: 10

"whoo hoo"

by: Consensus

date: November 20, 2007

this was fantastic, i really enjoyed the pipe and breakfast jokes (even tho, people who haven't read the books probably won't get them), looking forward to parts 2 & 3.

Score: 10

"Awesome"

by: SamIam

date: November 20, 2007

Glad to see another flash from you...Anyways that was awesome great job on the animation.

Score: 1

"Rather Pathetic"

by: TommyGun

date: November 20, 2007

The animation lacked direction, the art style was appaliing and the animation lack fluidity. The humour, if you could call it that, was rather sub-par to a point in which it was non-existant.

The characters seems too exist in their own universe rather than too relate to each other as any form of communication between several other characters seemd to create a false relationship.

Leanr to animate, learn to establish characters realtionships and for the love of mormon Jesus learn to develop proper narrative progression.