Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Score: 7

"A good attempt."

by: Jin

date: August 5, 2008

It's really a waste that it was a "first come, first serve" system, which gave weaker submissions a space that could be filled with better pictures.

There are good pictures, and there are bad ones. 2 of my submissions got in, one of them that was meant to be a funny sync with another picture which failed. I admit mine aren't one of the better, but I'm sure I have improved since.

Scrolling could be better if easing was used. Good music choice, good preloader. Good collab.

Score: 7

"Cool"

by: PlasmaPlatypus

date: June 25, 2008

I liked the flash alot, It's just that there were a lot of pics that were not that great, but their were some really good ones.

Score: 8

"kakkouii!!"

by: Zerowun

date: March 31, 2008

enjoyed this piece. watched it all the way through. watched it again and paused at each segment. well done, but not as seamless as the red line. seeing dora on the mountain did make me laugh. good work

Score: 6

"Not that great."

by: Dew

date: February 21, 2008

I mean coming from such a great masterpiece as the red line, I was expecting a lot out of this submission, and what I got was a lackluster submission. I mean it wasn't bad, but I mean, it wasn't great ether. The submission itself seemed to be a bunch of random drawing pasted together, which would have been great, had the drawings all been made well, which they weren't. Not something I liked.

Score: 10

"dfdf"

by: test-object

date: January 6, 2008

Such a long time ago... Looking back on it, I've improved a LOT! This drawing was crap. I remember the annoying greyish background I never really bothered to fix it 100 procent... ^^

I'm sorry I didn't nominate this thread for the Art Forum Award.

Score: 10

"(^_^)"

by: Kairukia

date: April 5, 2007

OMG this is awesome!!

Sound 10 - the music was brilliant

Style 10 - all these drawings, and the idea of them climbing up mt newgrounds... WEWT

Violence 3 - some of the drawings had violence

Humer 10 - some of the drawings made me laugh my head off

Graphics 10 - some good drawings & animations there

Overall 10 - BECAUSE IT WAS FRIGGIN AWESOME

Score: 10

"hmm..."

by: alone-with-death

date: April 3, 2007

completely forgot i did this nice to look back on it though ...good times lol

Score: 8

"Good..."

by: Mylovelydame21

date: March 31, 2007

But it didn't flow as smoothly as "The Red Line". There were lots of glitches and skips in the music. But overall, still very nice. I give it a "4".

Score: 7

"Failed to be consistent"

by: xscoot

date: March 2, 2007

This flash was good but failed to be as consistent as the red line. Also there were some really bad animation problems. Next time use better animation, and make a more specific concept or specific rules as some stuff just wasn't right (a mountain city at 70 ft?)

Score: 6

"hats off to all who worked hard in this collab."

by: Bezman

date: February 8, 2007

The song was brilliant and I liked the end-reveal and the peak animation, but there just didn't seem to be as high a standard of creativity as in the Red Line.

I really liked Memb's - nice use of custom brushes.

There were a few other pictures that were really technically accomplished. However, many of them seemed like pictures that had little or nothing to do with the mountain and would work equally well if the mountain was replaced with, say, a house, an abstract plane or a grassy field or whatever.

It was somewhat enjoyable to watch though and hats off to all who worked hard in this collab.