Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Score: 10

"lol gr8 job"

by: SiMpSoN-bRuVaS

date: April 13, 2008

firstly the reviewer below me must be ob crak. the flash was great i loved it, 11th finder lol, the harry potter quotes "muggle" ect were also great, sam lolol he was dressed like a girl. great idea dude great flash, this woulda been front page material if it werent for the ending,

OH AND SUPERMAN LOLOLOL

Score: 10

"Wow"

by: Jonimator

date: October 27, 2006

Well to start off i would like to say thank you,

Your animation inspired me! It's deep love story which occurred hidden within the animation almost made me cry. And yet I laughed at all jokes, making me cheer up once again.

I have put the violence at ten for Gandlaf nailing Frodo in the head. ( this gave me great laughter )
The sound was simply AMAZING!
Please tell Shamus his voice acting was superb. The only down side in this animation was some dumb white pointy arrow in the centre of the screen.

In closing I would like to Once more thank you for your great inspiring flash!

Take care man!

- John

Score: 7

"Well it was good."

by: demon-fox

date: September 2, 2006

But by no means perfect. The animation was quite choppy. And next time really work on getting a better Mic... it did sound kind of horrible when they spoke.

Although, interesting point you made here...

Pretty funny too.

Score: 10

"Hilarious"

by: Hellomrsockpuppet

date: September 2, 2006

Hahah hilarious.

Score: 6

"lol"

by: gaianmaster

date: September 2, 2006

lol that was pathetic but in a funny way.

Score: 7

"Funny"

by: Agnoeo

date: September 2, 2006

Pretty good and I like it, but what was with the eagle having an old union flag with the 13 stars? That confused me a little...

Score: 8

"NIce piece of work."

by: Silver-Paladin

date: September 2, 2006

Youve got a very cool syle! I like it! But here are some mistakes:

1. Graphic is a bit rough, suggest to figure about this more.
2. Voice talents are not so good.

But other than that. Stlye is very cool (Gandalf should had done that in the novel. LOL!!) Joke is funny (Sam is gay? Superman in the novel era? <another LoL!!>)

Nice piece of work!! 4/5

Score: 7

"lol"

by: w1sh

date: September 2, 2006

Yeah, why didn't they think of that?
Wtf... maybe he explained it somewhere in the book. Or maybe the eagles would've been tempted to the darkside if they held it. I dunno. wtf though. Thats the perfect solution. pwn dude...
pwwn....

Score: 4

"Umm.."

by: Jenna-di

date: September 2, 2006

The only reason I decided to watch this was because Lord of the Rings was in the title, and I regret my decision to watch it! Your right J.R.R Tolkien could have done just what you have illiustrated, but it was boring! I did, however, love the pictures and references to Elijah Wood's movies, seeing as I'm a big fan. I didn't like the fact you called him a pervert from Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind...one of my favourtie movies and not nice at all! It maybe in all fun and games, totally not funny at all!
Overall this animation was...a piece of crap! In my eyes, being a huge LOTR fan I wanted to scrap my eye balls out with a mellon baller and sell them over ebay it was that bad!

Score: 7

"Eh"

by: Rabid-Turtle

date: September 1, 2006

Well, it was funny until the end. The end sucks anus.