Reviews For: Forever Autumn

(154 Reviews • Avg: 7.96/10)

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There are 16 pages of reviews. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 91216 ]


Score: 9
GangstadanDT

"An Oscar Winner!"

date: September 28, 2008

Seeing your earlier works and seeing this, you have definately improved over the years. I can't wait to see your next work. Bright Eyes and Deliverance were my favorites, along with this jewel.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People find this review helpful!

Score: 10
silverscreen1

"about"

date: August 24, 2007

some pple ar confused about the car and the guy surviving a nuclear war

1 the guy was on a bussiness trip

2 the two airplanes were heading to drop nukes on the city

3 the car dies prop run out of petrol ot EMP

3 the guys in the nuked city recalling ren he arrived

4 there was no violence becuse the role dint require it

5 there was animations

6 there was no porn becuse i cant see the appeal of ass and tities

constructive criticism ignoring becuse the flash spoke for itself

silverscreen1

Same
Side
Forward
Same
Oriantation

August 24, 2007

Author's Response:

Attempted Translation and a Response!

Some people are confused about the car and the guy surviving the nuclear war.
1. The guy was on a business trip. (Maybe?)
2. The two airplanes were heading to drop nukes on the city. (Not so much.)
3. The car dies due to a lack of gas or to the effects of an EMP. (The first)
4. The guy is the nuked city is recalling when he arrived. (Not so much.)
4. There was no violence because the movie did not require it. (Sure!)
5. There was no animation. (No animation is good animation!)
6. There was no porn because the movie did not require it. (Or did it?!)

Constructive critisism has been ignored because the flash spoke for itself. (K.)

Silverscreen1

Same
Side
Forward
Same
Orientation

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People think this is a useless review.

Score: 10
Clatuu

"I love it"

by: Clatuu
date: June 21, 2007

You i may have said that while reviewing your other submissions. but very well made and shaking.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
Zen-Trai

"You are an amazing artist"

date: June 9, 2007

This entire flash was amazing and had me in awe the whole time, I don't even know where to begin on how good it was, the character was drawn beautifully as well as the planes, the car, the buildings, hell, everything was beautifully drawn, I couldn't see any thing that was bad or didn't fit, I'm surprised this isn’t in the top 50, something like this should be in the top five I think.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
Stickiller

"Spectacular"

date: January 17, 2007

One of the most beautiful flash movies I've ever seen, and it has one of the most beautiful songs, too. The idea to use this song to follow a man in the middle of a nuclear winter is genius. And, visually, this movie is scary because of its amazing portrayal of the aftermath of a nuclear attack.

My favorite scene is when the performer sings "I watch the birds fly south across the autumn sky" and, instead of birds, it's a couple of battle aircrafts... a metaphor that blew me away. Fantastic. And, though the whole movie is a composition of static symbols... it NEVER gets boring, because of the amazing way you draw every scene. In the scene I mentioned above, the camera showing the airplanes flying away panning down to show the protagonist's car was a hell of a camera move.

Only flaw? The fact the character's expression doesn't change and his staticness. But that barely does any damage to the movie. Also, congratulations for the beautiful menu with the plane flying across the clouds.

All in all, a beautiful, touching flash-movie. You have a LOT of talent, David.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 9
BouncyTEM

"Very good message. One minor flaw."

date: November 25, 2006

Extremely good message in this video. I'm touched.

Thank you, sir, for trying to bring out the truths of nuclear devastation. There's only one major part missing, though.

Not many people consider what hordes of nuclear bombs would cause to the atmosphere. With that many massive explosions going on at once..the ash in the atmosphere would be horrific, and if you launch enough, could block out the sun. If that happens, welcome Nuclear Winter. If enough is launched, the winter can even reach 100 years. Plants wouldn't be able to survive a 10 year nuclear winter, let alone 100. We'd all suffocate to death if the plants died off. So...if we launch nukes...goodbye all life.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
crimson-guard

"excellent"

date: October 26, 2006

This is an incredible flash. It's like a dramatic music video, I hope the author produces more high quality content like this despite the nay sayers.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 9
thewxman

"I was moved by the images. Great song"

date: August 20, 2006

Could this possibly be an omen of what is to come? The animation was very good and of course the Moody Blues made it even more moving. Great choice of song selection. I hope to see more of your work. You're very talented.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People think this is a useless review.

Score: 9
UMACS

"MOVED ME ALOT, GREAT FLASH....."

by: UMACS
date: August 17, 2006

really great flash, i look forward to your next flash. If you make another one why not make it on the current war on error and how it will progress into WWIII. your very good at this type of scenario why not give it a try...

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 8
InvaderLupus

"Nice video"

date: August 14, 2006

The video was excellent, and full of style and mood. The art was great.

I almost laughed out loud when the credits rolled though, because I thought that itunes must have randomly started playing, because I have that mp3 of Air (the one from End of Evangelion) on it.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There are 16 pages of reviews. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 91216 ]