Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Checking login status…

USERNAME:

PASSWORD:

Logging in…

Logged in as:
.
Logging out…
Inbox My Account Log Out


Reviews For: Autumn Tree

(1,360 Reviews • Avg: 8.86/10)

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There are 136 pages of reviews. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 771136 ]


Score: 10
Sub-Zero9090

"amazing"

date: November 28, 2007

that was very very good. i wish stuff like this never happened. god man, just thinking about it makes me mad. very good work. i cant imagine doing anything like that. i hope those two fuckers burn in hell

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People aren't in agreement over whether this is helpful or not.

Score: 10
madcowfun

"................"

date: November 26, 2007

this was a true story the girl whom they killed under the table is called casey

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 5
ToXicCrack

"Meh"

date: November 23, 2007

This obviously took a lot of time and skill to make. However I found it to be a lot like Elephant which was a pretty shitty movie (Zero Day is waaaaaay better). I don't get why the names and appearances of the killers changed but the location remained the same. Also about the Manson thing, neither Reb or V listened to him, they liked Rammstein, KMFDM ect. and I even read that Reb hated Manson. IDK, I just think that in my mind it resembled Elephant too much (same dialogue when meeting the Brookes character, similar scenes with them looking at the rifle, going over the plans, in the car, walking up the path, shooting the authoritative figure, and the ending without a conclusion), I probably would have been more pleased it it resembled the Zero Hour Massacre At Columbine documentary or the movie Zero Day... or was completely original. It was very well made though, not like some of the other movies on here that look like they were drawn by a 5th grader. So I give it a half and half.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 9
Radiohead07

"The Best I've seen"

date: November 22, 2007

I thought that this flash was mostly accurate with everything. People don't understand that your really cant get all of the facts really because no one really knows what happened. If its not a burden do you think you could post the music that you used in this flash.
Good job

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
sestherapy1

"This is what people get wrong"

date: November 19, 2007

People just don't seem to understand that this movie wasn't meant to be a step by step one hundred percent accurate thing.
I've read a couple of reviews on this and half of the people who leave comments are dumb or talk about the shooting as if they were there when it happened.
I'm going to admit that I'm not against what eric and dylan did but I'm not going to talk about them in a way that makes me seem ignorant
Great movie by the way 10/10 all the way it's my favorite flash on newgrounds because I find it to be the most complex video
I would have loved to have this in my ipod I'd probably watch it every day
anyway I'm off

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 0
Lemmy26

"not even wikipedia was sooooo... uncurrect"

date: November 17, 2007

DYLAN AND ERIC DONT LISTEN TO MARYLIN MANSON!!!!, look, im not fan of Manson, i dont like his music, but is stupid believe that guys make the massacre just for listen his music that not make scence in any way (same way for videogames, if that will be true, Japan will have 10 massacres at day). Dylan and Eric make the massacre because they are psychos who believe they are gods with rage problems, thats all. very bad movie =(

November 21, 2007

Author's Response:

You are totally getting this the wrong way. We never said that listening to Marilyn Manson was the cause of what happened or the video games. Hell, we purposely didn't make the videogame in the movie violent. So this is just your narrow way of seeing it really.
However, it remains a fact that they listened to heavy metal music (Rammstein, Manson etc), they loved the movie Natural Born Killers and that they played alot of video games. So you are saying that because this were their interests that we should leave these details out on purpose? What type of bullshit is that? We tried to put them into the surrounding in which this happened and to put little details in it. That doesn't mean we think the Manson sticker on his bag was the cause, that's just silly.
We didn't make any form of judgement in the movie, we took neither the side of Eric or Dylan nor the one of the school victims. We leave the interpretation up to the viewer. But please don't force your own interpretation down our throats, saying this is what we meant with it, because you are way off the mark.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People think this is a useless review.

Score: 10
sndub26

"I agree with Shuzenbu"

date: November 16, 2007

Even if those kids went about solving their problems the wrong way, we should still remember that they were treated like crap. Not that what they did was justifiable on any level, but people should just pay attention to the needs of others. Why is that so hard?

I love this, I always found it hard to visualize what it must have been like for the victims. Fantastic job.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
Kaotyc

"Sad"

by: Kaotyc
date: November 14, 2007

not right, if they got bullied then why not bully the bullies? thats how i got through life i sortedthings out with my fists and i dont get no problem now! They are just like Emos depressed and pissed off with the rest of the world for what happened! Why take it out on others!? Then again those ignorant peices of.... are not alive today, and thank goodness some people made it out alive!
Good film given it a 10/10 and 5/5 on the other rating thingy.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People think this is a useless review.

Score: 10
Shuzenbu

"There was a lesson."

date: November 11, 2007

A lesson to be learned from that day at Columbine. Those two kids were tortured, and pushed to the breaking point. There last feelings in life were of desperation and dispair just like the victims that they claimed. But at least most of there victims probobly had more enjoyable lives than them untill that point. The real sad truth behind this though is that As a whole, America learned nothing that day. Columbine quickly became just another thing that the "Norm" crowds would whisper amongst themselves as any of thier "less than normal" classmates passed by. I think the two killers at Columbine were trying to send a message. One that was widely, unrecieved. Sadly, the situation only became worse for any students in the Jr./Highschool agegroup. And it only seems like school shootings became more frequent thereafter. OH! How sad.... is the world?

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People find this review helpful!

Score: 7
Swim-The-Swan

""Elephant" Anyone?"

date: November 10, 2007

Im guessing that this was inspired by the movie "Elephant". Alot of scenes in this where really similar to those in the film. The scene where they tell the kid in the parking lot that "serious shit is about to happen". The scene where the teacher runs and gets shot in the back and the kid says 'bitch'. Some of it was accurate aswell such as the "do you believe in god?" bit and the part where 'andy' comes up and they let him go(though i think the real kid had a different name).

Another thing I noticed is the music you used, its also from the film Elephant. I can understand being influenced by that movie, its really a mind blower. I give this cartoon a 7/10

November 11, 2007

Author's Response:

Thanks for the review. Elephant is indeed a very good movie. However, all the situations in the flash were animated after research. The 'serious shit is about to happen' part was literally said according to wikipedia. The only part similar to elephant is the 'bitch' part.
The music isn't from elephant either. The main score is by Fernando Sor, a classical composer who i stumbled upon after browsing through my cd collection. The other songs have nothing to do with elephant either.
I think some people compare this to Elephant because it basically uses the same approach on the theme. A very nihilistic, almost documentary approach. I think this is the only approach that works for the columbine topic. Putting the emphasis on action, drama or personal opinion would ruin the movie in my opinion.
Thanks for the review

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There are 136 pages of reviews. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 771136 ]