Score: 3
"Good idea, poorly executed."
date: June 13, 2009
GOOD: Gollum ending up on the Dr. Phil show was a very clever idea. The conversation between them gave me a kick or two.
BAD: Lack of animation, poor graphics and synching. The sound clips were a bit fuzzy and the background noise didn't help too much.
IMPROVE: First off, you can improve the graphics and add in more animation because it looked like you rushed this and tried to avoid as much animation as possible. You can add more animation by making body language between the two and when Gollum attacked Dr. Phil, you could show the fighting. You could also use some more clear clips if you can and perhaps better sound synching.
OVERALL: It was a good idea but poorly executed. You did a lazy job on this despite its charm with humorous conversation between Gollum and Dr. Phil. You need to put in more effort and make it more visually appealing or otherwise the sound is the only thing about this flash worth viewing.
If anyone is interested, try making Gollum on the Maury Povich show or the Jerry Springer show.
