Which is the best?

[Fate]

I'm working on a flash at the moment, that requires an alien, of sorts, and I can't decide what look I want, so I've decided to bring it to the people of Newgrounds.
Can you help me decide which one is the best? or the best parts of all of them, that I can combine to create a good one.
they're are numbered like this;
123
456
789

I'm hoping for a more..innocent look, that people can, maybe, get attached to.

Pleasetell me which number, and...if you're bored, why.
I'd appreciate the help

[remspoorman]

there's a flash forum for this

[MattyT]

i like the first one

[Fate]

One problem.
It's not about flash, it's about which alien is better.

There's mods for what you're attempting to do.

[Insanimation]

At 11/22/08 07:25 AM, remspoorman wrote: there's a flash forum for this

This isn't about the actual Flash program. It should be here, IMO.

I like the body of 2 with the feet of 5. I think..

[joabos]

At 11/22/08 07:25 AM, remspoorman wrote: there's a flash forum for this

This isn't about flash.
Also, those are in my opinion, the best drawn:

[Fate]

At 11/22/08 07:27 AM, PrivateJoker92 wrote: i like the first one

hmm, I've attempted to do a less drafty version of it. See below.

At 11/22/08 07:31 AM, joabos wrote: Also, those are in my opinion, the best drawn:

yeah. The one that looks like the Pacman ghost is actually from another animation I had been working on, but haven't finished, probably never will.
But...Most of them are drafts.
it was...just more of the general...shapes and ideas, than drawing quality.
but thanks a heap.

At the moment, I'm leaning towards this one.
What's the thought on colours?
for the animation, it'd...probably be the only red item, whereas there's a lot of blues and greens, so i edged away from them.

[joabos]

At 11/22/08 07:37 AM, NightBreaker wrote:
yeah. The one that looks like the Pacman ghost is actually from another animation I had been working on, but haven't finished, probably never will.
But...Most of them are drafts.
it was...just more of the general...shapes and ideas, than drawing quality.
but thanks a heap.

At the moment, I'm leaning towards this one.
What's the thought on colours?
for the animation, it'd...probably be the only red item, whereas there's a lot of blues and greens, so i edged away from them.

Just my opinion, but i liked him more white, or gray with the little ball on his head of some other color.

[Fate]

At 11/22/08 07:40 AM, joabos wrote: Just my opinion, but i liked him more white, or gray with the little ball on his head of some other color.

hmmmm.
it's a valid point.
but since I've already done the second draft, I'll put it up and see what you think.

[joabos]

At 11/22/08 07:45 AM, NightBreaker wrote:

At 11/22/08 07:40 AM, joabos wrote: Just my opinion, but i liked him more white, or gray with the little ball on his head of some other color.

hmmmm.
it's a valid point.
but since I've already done the second draft, I'll put it up and see what you think.

Looks pretty good, thought you could put some reflect on that ball on his head.
Like this:
If you change your mind though, feel free to use my idea.

[Fate]

At 11/22/08 07:48 AM, joabos wrote: Looks pretty good, thought you could put some reflect on that ball on his head.
Like this:
If you change your mind though, feel free to use my idea.

No, that's a good idea. I didn't consider it to be a shiny object, but now that you've shown me, it actually looks a heap better. So I probably will use that. thanks.

At 11/22/08 07:28 AM, fish1892 wrote: I like the body of 2 with the feet of 5. I think..

would it look a little like this?
(+ color, which is undecided)

[Dromedary]

http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/forum/2
/
http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/forum/14

[Fate]

At 11/22/08 07:59 AM, doody1 wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/forum/2
/
http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/forum/14

*sighs*
This may have something to do with Flash and Art, that is not the discussion of this thread.
If you noticed, it's where the better alien is decided, so I feel that you are incorrect.

[joabos]

At 11/22/08 07:56 AM, NightBreaker wrote:

At 11/22/08 07:48 AM, joabos wrote: Looks pretty good, thought you could put some reflect on that ball on his head.
Like this:
If you change your mind though, feel free to use my idea.

No, that's a good idea. I didn't consider it to be a shiny object, but now that you've shown me, it actually looks a heap better. So I probably will use that. thanks.

At 11/22/08 07:28 AM, fish1892 wrote: I like the body of 2 with the feet of 5. I think..

would it look a little like this?
(+ color, which is undecided)

Why don't you make the flash with them both? You could change their colors to make them contrast.
Also, as doody1 said, art forum D: