At 8/26/08 01:51 PM, Ragnarokia wrote:
Yellow, is the Y a vowel, no, as such Y is not a vowel. SIMPLE.
Cyst. Is the Y a vowel, yes, as such Y is a vowel. Also Simple.
The argument that Y cannot be both a vowel and a consonant is only a valid one if you're looking at a single instance.
Vowels and consonants are sounds, not letters. The letters are then classified as vowels or consonants by the sounds they make.
A vowel is a sound inherently syllabic, such that in and of itself it will form a complete syllable descriptive of its sound. A consonant however requires a vowel to be syllabically pronounced. T: tee, teh, tuh, tah, tih, etc.
Then, Y: e, i, why, yah. Y can exist as both a vowel (e, i) or consonant (why, yah), just not at the same time.
As far as classification of the letters go irrespective of specific instance (i.e. in general) Y can be referred to as a vocoid. If you were to look at a ven diagram, you would have a vowel circle and a consonant circle. Where they cross you would find vocoids.
Regardless of what you want to call the letter, the sounds produced by the Y's in words such as cyst and rhythm are vowels. Therefore, the words contain vowels.