At 7/21/08 05:34 PM, FalconPunch wrote:
1: Resort to sarcasm means that you are basically done with the argument.
Coming from someone who refused to propose an argument.
2: You still haven't provided any consequenses which means that you do in fact have a bias in your argument. Since you are to incompetent to list any I will do so.
This statement proves your idiocy in leaps in bounds, you asked me to argue agaisnt myself, then when I asked you to do your own arguing you tell me I'm biased and incompetent.
Vitamin B12 deficiency - Vitamin B12 can only be obtained through meat-based products. Ingesting any form of Vitamin B12 means that you have taken part of killing the animal for reasons to stay alive. It is hypocritical to state otherwise.
You see you believe that Vitamin b12 is an animal byproduct, but you are mistaken, Vitamin B12 is formed from bacteria, it is found on the skin of all fruits and vegetables. In fact the only reason animals have Vitamin B12 in their meat is because they get it off the food they eat (same idea goes for protein too actually). And most of the Vitamin B12 put into foods (such as cereal) or in vitamin supplements comes from yeast, not meat.
Protein deficiency - This one is a bit dodgy. Some people have it and some people don;t. It's as simple as that.
Most people don't, protein and the amino acids that create protein are available in pretty much every form of food outside of meat. Vegetables, beans, nuts, fruit, grains.
Overeating - Since Vegetarians need to obtain protein through means of beans, eggs or other food sources which aren't as protein-rich as meat it encourages vegetarians to eat more of those foods just to gain the necessary protein which can lead to extensive amounts of other essentials which can harm you over time.
You realize that the levels at which vitamins start producing adverse effects are leaps and bounds above the normal intake level?
Information from http://www.wdxcyber.com/ngen21.htm
Vitamin A recommended daily intake=2,600 IU
When vitamin A begins to produce adverse effects=21,600 IU
Vitamin E = 12 UI
No adverse effects at 1,200 UI and no established Lowest level of intake to produce adverse effects.
Etc..
3: Having "feelings" is one thing but if the animal itself can't comprehend them then they mean absolutely nothing. In today's society captivity is almost necessary for animals to even survive at all. Insulting me based on a false idea of yours is idiotic. Your idea states that a domestic cat would rather live in an alley living off of restaurant scraps than live in a loving environment in which the animal receives plenty of food, sleep, play and attention. Your idea of the lack of all those being better is completely insane.
Okay a cage where you can't move your limbs and have your lips cutoff is not the same as the ideal environment you are suggesting for the cat. The animal can comprehend it's own feelings, to acknowledge that an animal can have feelings but not understand them doesn't even make sense, it's like saying that we can feel happy but we don't know what happy is. Well you know it when you feel it. Your belief that captivity is necessary for an animals survival is highly illogical and an argument less based on fact than your attack on the idea of an IQ.